IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY, VOL. 50, NO. 1, FEBRUARY 2008 175
Multiconductor Reduction Technique for Modeling
Common-Mode Currents on Cable Bundles at High
Frequency for Automotive Applications
Guillaume Andrieu, Lamine Kon´ e, Fr´ ed´ eric Bocquet, Bernard D´ emoulin, and Jean-Philippe Parmantier
Abstract—This paper presents the fundamentals of the so-called
“Equivalent Cable Bundle Method” for the calculation over a large
frequency range of common-mode currents induced on cable bun-
dles by an electromagnetic (EM) perturbation. In particular, the
method aims at overcoming the limitation of the multiconductor
transmission line theory (MTLN), which is based on the propaga-
tion of the quasi-transverse EM (TEM) mode and efficiently used
only at “low frequencies.” The purpose of the method described
here is to reduce the computation time by reducing the complex-
ity of the cable bundle models. After a short presentation of the
“high frequency” coupling problem, first, the theoretical basis of
the method, and, second, the numerical and experimental valida-
tions performed on prototypal cable bundles, in order to illustrate
the efficiency and the advantages of the method, are presented. The
method described in this paper is considered as a required first step
in order to prepare wider applications on real systems in the near
future.
Index Terms—Cable bundle, cable harness, electromagnetic
topology, numerical modeling.
I. INTRODUCTION
A
S FOR many industrial domains such as aeronautics, the
capability to generate a full numerical model of a car has
become a strategic challenge in the automotive industry in order
to improve the design and the production of future automobiles.
To reach this goal, a huge effort is made in parallel to elaborate
operative modeling techniques and to provide the required
system input data (geometry, wiring, electrical circuits, etc.) to
the models in the most efficient way. This paper addresses the
particular aspect of cable bundle modeling techniques, which
we call later “high frequencies (HFs),” typically above some
gigahertz. Indeed, this frequency region is of particular interest
for the possible interference generated by new HF sources
such as Bluetooth or global system for mobile communication
(GSM) devices.
Manuscript received June 18, 2007; revised September 20, 2007. This work
was supported in part by the IEMN Laboratory, University of Lille, Villeneuve
d’Ascq, France, and in part by the RENAULT Company, Guyancourt, France.
G. Andrieu was with the IEMN Laboratory, Group Telice, University of Lille,
59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq Cedex, France, and also with Renault Technocentre,
78288 Guyancourt, France. He is now with the Xlim Laboratory, University of
Limoges, 87000 Limoges, France (e-mail: guillaume.andrieu@xlim.fr).
L. Kon´ e and B. D´ emoulin are with the IEMN Laboratory, Group
Telice, University of Lille, 59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq Cedex, France (e-mail:
lamine.kone@univ-lille1.fr; bernard.demoulin@univ-lille1.fr).
F. Bocquet is with Renault Technocentre, 78288 Guyancourt, France (e-mail:
frederic.bocquet@renault.com).
J.-P. Parmantier is with the Office National d’Etudes et de
Recherches A´ erospatiales (ONERA), 31055 Toulouse, France (e-mail: jean-
philippe.parmantier@onecert.fr).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TEMC.2007.911914
The multiconductor transmission line network (MTLN) the-
ory provides efficient models to estimate electromagnetic (EM)
coupling on a cable harness due to an electromagnetic excitation.
The main advantages of the MTLN formalism applied on mul-
ticonductor cable models are the calculation accuracy and the
computation time reduction compared to numerical techniques
that solve Maxwell’s equations (3-D codes).
In the past 15 years, thanks to the use of electromagnetic
topology formalism [1]–[3] for decomposing a complex elec-
tronic system such as a car into elementary subsystems, the
MTLN theory has led to efficient and encouraging calculations
of complex systems [4], [5]. In the automotive domain, the
field-to-TL approach is widely applied at the design level
[6]–[8]. The 3-D computer codes are used to calculate tangential
electric fields along the cable paths as a first step. As a second
step, they are introduced as source terms in the MTLN cable
harness models [9]–[11]. Moreover, over the last few years,
automobile constructors have made efforts to develop precise
numerical models of vehicles in which cable bundle models are
the most accurate as possible.
Unfortunately, the MTLN models become deficient when the
height of the cable above a ground reference increases, with
an averaged limit commonly set at a fifth of the wavelength.
Various techniques have been proposed with success in order
to extend their field of application [12]–[15]. However, in our
study, we choose to keep using 3-D codes at “high frequen-
cies.” Despite the constant progress in computer performance,
it is still impossible to perform an accurate calculation on a
realistic 3-D code model of an entire car including its metal-
lic parts and its complete cable harness. This is mainly due to
the computation time and the memory required for this kind of
problem. Consequently, this paper presents a method that allows
one to overcome this limitation with a methodology based on
the reduction of the multiconductor cable complexity already
addressed in several previous papers [16]–[18]. The so-called
“Equivalent Cable Bundle Method” that we propose here only
provides the common-mode current induced at the extremity of
simplified cable structures. The main assumption is that, as far
as EM coupling to the cable is concerned, the common-mode
response is more critical than the differential-mode response.
II. PROBLEM OF HF COUPLINGS ON CABLE BUNDLES
A. Frequency Limitation of MTLN Formalism
1) Appearance of Additional Phenomena: It is well known
that the MTLN theory is based on the propagation of a
0018-9375/$25.00 © 2008 IEEE