Fascist space and film: spatial practice and ideology in El Valle
de los Caídos (1963) and La sombra de la cruz (2013)
Katherine O. Stafford
Department of Languages and Literary Studies, Lafayette College, Easton, PA, USA
ABSTRACT
This article analyzes how film reproduces and/or contests the
spatial practices of the most emblematic fascist monument in
Spain, the Valley of the Fallen. I focus on two documentary
representations of the monument made by foreigners, Hollywood
director Andrew Marton’s El Valle de los Caídos (1963) and Italian
Alessandro Pugno’s La sombra de la cruz (2013). I analyze how
montage and cinematography tell a story of a Francoist space in
two distinct moments in time. Though products of considerably
different historical and social contexts, both documentaries tell a
similar narrative of a monk who joins the Benedictine order
located in the Valley, and both works seek to translate a national
Spanish essence to a wider audience through a cinematic
representation of a symbolic space. Marton’s film, a product of
Samuel Bronston Productions, is a performance of the spatial
aspirations and ideals of the Franco regime: we observe a “will to
architecture” and a desire to create or recreate what Lefebvre
calls “absolute space” through long shots and a filmic-
cartographic aviator gaze. In the contemporary film La sombra de
la cruz (2013), the gaze is dissonant and full of temporal and
spatial contrasts, revealing the fragility, frictional core and threat
of fascist spatial practice and ideology. Ultimately, this article
reflects on the legacy of Francoist space in Spain and how the
filmic gaze has evolved in response.
KEYWORDS
Spain; fascism; space;
memory; film
It was 1 April 1964, and Francisco Franco’s dictatorial regime celebrated its “25 Years of
Peace” campaign with religious ceremonies across Spain. The main event was a “Te
Deum” composed by José María Morales in the recently inaugurated Valley of the
Fallen, a monument built to commemorate the fallen “heroes and martyrs” of the
Spanish Civil War (1936–1939). Franco, his family and his appointed Bourbon heir to
the dictatorship, Prince Juan Carlos, were in attendance. It was the height of the monu-
ment’s prestige. Later, this striking edifice would gradually transform into a kind of
“pariah” space, as well as one of the most costly and subsidized sites of Spanish national
patrimony. As I write this, its identity is in limbo.
1
As Rafael Rodríguez Tranche and Vicente Sánchez-Biosca (2018, 496–497) note, the
success and impact of the Valley of the Fallen was ultimately limited because the
© 2022 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
CONTACT Katherine O. Stafford staffoko@lafayette.edu
JOURNAL OF SPANISH CULTURAL STUDIES
https://doi.org/10.1080/14636204.2022.2107755
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
CJSC2107755 Techset Composition India (P) Ltd., Bangalore and Chennai, India 7/29/2022