Abstract— Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is the most common cause,
(after trauma) of neurological disability in young adults in
Western countries. While several Magnetic Resonance Imaging
(MRI) studies have demonstrated a strong association between
the presence of cortical grey matter atrophy and the progression
of neurological impairment in MS patients, the neurobiological
substrates of cortical atrophy in MS, and in particular its
relationship with white matter (WM) and cortical lesions,
remain unknown. The aim of this study was to investigate the
interplay between cortical atrophy and different types of lesions
at Ultra-High Field (UHF) 7 T MRI, including cortical lesions
and lesions with a susceptibility rim (a feature which
histopathological studies have associated with impaired
remyelination and progressive tissue destruction). We combined
lesion characterization with a recent machine learning (ML)
framework which includes explainability, and we were able to
predict cortical atrophy in MS from a handful of lesion-related
features extracted from 7 T MR imaging. This highlights not
only the importance of UHF MRI for accurately evaluating
intracortical and rim lesion load, but also the differential
contributions that these types of lesions may bring to determine
disease evolution and severity. Also, we found that a small subset
of features [WM lesion volume (not considering rim lesions),
patient age and WM lesion count (not considering rim lesions),
intracortical lesion volume] carried most of the prediction
power. Interestingly, an almost opposite pattern emerged when
contrasting cortical with WM lesion load: WM lesion load is
most important when it is small, whereas cortical lesion load
behaves in the opposite way.
Clinical Relevance— Our results suggest that disconnection
and axonal degeneration due to WM lesions and local cortical
demyelination are the main factors determining cortical
thinning. These findings further elucidate the complexity of MS
pathology across the whole brain and the need for both statistical
and mechanistic approaches to understanding the
etiopathogenesis of lesions.
I. INTRODUCTION
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is one of the most common causes
of neurological disability in young adults in the Western
world [1]. Different radiological features, such as brain
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) “demyelinating” lesions
and grey matter (GM) atrophy, are commonly used to
diagnose and evaluate disease progression in MS patients [2].
*
This work was supported by grants from the National Multiple Sclerosis
Society (NMSS 4281-RG-A1 and NMSS RG 4729A2/1), National Institutes
of Health R01NS078322-01-A1, and United States Army W81XWH-13-1-
0122.
# These authors contributed equally to this work
A.C. and N.T. are with the Department of Biomedicine and Prevention,
University of Rome “Tor Vergata”, C.A.T., A. M., V.T.B. and C.M. are with
Several MRI studies have shown that GM atrophy arises
early in the course of the disease and accelerates with disease
progression [3], and additional studies have also
demonstrated a strong association between GM atrophy and
neurological impairment in MS patients [4] evaluable through
functional MRI [5]. As cortical atrophy seems to be the main
driver of GM atrophy [6], the understanding of the
neurobiological substrates and main determinants of cortical
atrophy in MS could be instrumental in predicting disease
progression and stratifying the disease subtypes.
Cortical (both intracortical and leukocortical)
demyelinated lesions constitute a substantial part of the total
lesion load in MS brain [7]. In addition, MS patients may
exhibit chronically active white matter lesions, which are
identifiable on susceptibility-weighted MR images by their
characteristic paramagnetic rim (commonly called “rim
lesions”) [8], [9]. While both cortical and rim lesions load as
well as cortical atrophy are relevant for the diagnosis and the
evaluation of MS progression, very little is known about their
interplay and, in particular, about how the differential
occurrence of one or more types of lesion may be related to
cortical atrophy. In this context, it is not clear whether cortical
atrophy is mainly the result of local pathological processes or,
instead, disconnection from other brain regions which may
result by the disruption caused by white matter (WM) lesions.
A strong limitation in the investigation of this question is the
ability to actually detect and differentiate cortical and rim
lesions (as well as of evaluating their extension) when
employing MR scanners equipped with static fields with
intensities typically found in clinical centers (3T or even
1.5T) [10]. This often allows clinicians to detect and evaluate
only a small portion of lesions. In this context, recent studies
have demonstrated that ultra-high field (UHF) human MRI
(7T) significantly improves in vivo imaging of both cortical
and rim lesions in MS patients [11], [12]. UHF radiological
findings are therefore of strong clinical relevance and may
represent the best candidates for investigating the differential
role of all lesion types in the progression of cortical atrophy
in patients affected by MS.
The aim of this study was to understand the interplay
between cortical thickness and different types of lesions, by
leveraging radiological markers (cortical and rim lesion load
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, United States. C.M., A. M., V.T.B
and N.T. are also with A. A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging,
Boston, United States.
Corresponding author: Allegra Conti. E-mail: allegra.conti@uniroma2.it.
An interpretable machine learning model to explain the interplay
between brain lesions and cortical atrophy in multiple sclerosis
A. Conti, C.A. Treaba, A. Mehndiratta, V.T. Barletta, C. Mainero
#
, and N. Toschi
#
, Senior Member,
IEEE
2021 43rd Annual International Conference of the
IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC)
Oct 31 - Nov 4, 2021. Virtual Conference
978-1-7281-1178-0/21/$31.00 ©2021 IEEE 3757