Natural Resources, 2010, 1, 57-68
doi:10.4236/nr.2010.12006 Published Online December 2010 (http://www.SciRP.org/journal/nr)
Copyright © 2010 SciRes. NR
57
From Thaer and Thünen until Today: Past and
Future of Agricultural Landscape Use in Germany
Harald Kaechele
1
, Sunil Nautiyal
2
1
Leibniz-Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research (ZALF), Institute of Socioeconomics, Eberswalder, Muencheberg, Germany;
2
Centre for Ecological Economics and Natural Resources, Institute for Social and Economic Change, Nagarabhavi, Bangalore, India.
Email: nautiyal_sunil@rediffmail.com
Received October 12
th
, 2010; revised November 13
th
, 2010; accepted November 15
th
, 2010.
ABSTRACT
This article intends to present the historical development of German agriculture sector over the last several decades
and underlined the benefit of the advancement in agriculture sector to fulfill the growing food demand. At the same time
the article discussed the ecological and socio-economic viewpoint of rapid technological development of agriculture
sector in Germany. It would facilitate the debate on technological advancement in agriculture sector, which rapidly
developing throughout the world, in the perspective of ongoing climate change and corresponding limit of sustainable
socio-ecological development.
Keywords: Agricultural Landscape, Energy Efficiency, Sustainable Agriculture, Technological Development, Climate
Change
1. Introduction
When Albrecht Daniel Thaer purchased the estate at
Möglin in 1804, it was his intention to lay the founda-
tions of rational agriculture. The highly successful physi-
cian had realised quite early that the low productivity of
the agricultural and silvicultural land use of that time
could be overcome by means of appropriate management
systems [1]. Thaer criticised the poor soil culture of the
agricultural lands. For years he had been sustaining the
double work burden as physician and agronomist. But
from 1804 on he devoted his activity exclusively to agri-
cultural matters having in mind the improvement of the
art of field husbandry by overcoming the deficiencies
found in the way land was being managed. His ‘Princi-
ples of Rational Agriculture’ (1809-1812) published in
four volumes, are generally regarded as the very founda-
tion-stone of modern agricultural sciences [2]. Thaer
perceived agriculture as an industry which would have to
be performed in a sustainable and profit-orientated man-
ner [1,3]. Thus he postulated two criteria which even 200
years after him have not lost any of their validity: Effi-
cient agriculture, as we understand it today, is defined, to
a considerable degree, by economic success. Furthermore,
the idea of sustainability as demanded by Thaer, deter-
mines the current debate on land use even when this
concept has experienced a significant impetus over the
past decades. Thaer insisted on the long-term and durable
perspective in farming which this concept implies. But
today, against the background of the dramatic decline of
the natural bases of life, the ecological dimension of our
actions has increasingly come under public scrutiny. In
principle, this does not question Thaer’s demand for a
rational agriculture, but is just made more precise in the
light of recent developments and findings.
The evolution of agricultural land use has, since Thaer’s
times, revealed a hitherto unprecedented dynamics.
Whilst until the mid-20th century not even 10 people
were fed by one agricultural worker, this ratio was 1:126
in 2004! Since 1950 labour productivity in farming hence
has been rising at an annual rate of over 6%. Which have
been the factors contributing to this unparalleled boost in
productivity achieved over a few decades which allowed
to overcome the deficient soil culture stated by Thaer?
And how does the outcome of a 200-year evolution look
like under the perspective of the sustainability postulate
introduced by Thaer? This paper is intended to help an-
swering these questions, i.e. to make a contribution in
terms of reflecting the developments of Central-Euro-
pean agriculture starting with the situation as encoun-
tered by Thaer and further on until today’s highly effi-
cient agricultural production. It was at Möglin over 200
years ago where the foundations were conceived and
later on deepened and further developed by the pupils of