Factors Associated With Medication-Related Problems in
Ambulatory Hemodialysis Patients
HaroldJ.Manley,PharmD,MarcyL.McClaran,RN,DebraK.Overbay,PharmD,
MarciaA.Wright,PharmD,GeraldM.Reid,MD,WalterL.Bender,MD,TimothyK.Neufeld,MD,
SudarshanHebbar,MD,andRichardS.Muther,MD
● Background: Hemodialysis (HD) patients are at risk for medication-related problems. Patient characteristics
associated with the number of medication-related problems in HD patients have not been investigated. Methods:
Patientrecordswerereviewedtoidentifymedicalproblems,prescribedmedications,medicationindication(s),and
medication-related problems. Medication classes and medication-related problems were compared between pa-
tients with and without diabetes mellitus (DM). Correlations were performed to determine whether associations
existbetweenmedication-relatedproblems,numberofmedications,numberofmedicationdosesperday,number
of comorbid conditions, patient age, and duration of end-stage renal disease while controlling for DM status.
Results: Medicalrecordsof133patientswereevaluated.Patientswere60.5 15.2yearsold,prescribed11.0 4.2
medications, and had 6.0 2.3 comorbidities. Medication-related problems were identified in 97.7% of patients.
Four hundred seventy-five medication-related problems were identified, averaging 3.6 1.8 medication-related
problemsperpatient.PatientswithDMhadmoremedication-relatedproblemsidentifiedthanthosewithoutDM(303
versus172medication-relatedproblems,respectively; P < 0.05).Medication-relatedproblemscorrelatedpositively
withnumberofpatientcomorbidities(P < 0.001). Conclusion: Medication-relatedproblemsareprevalentinvirtually
all HD patients. The number of medication-related problems in an individual patient increases as the number of
comorbid conditions increases. The most frequent medication-related problems were drug without indication
(30.9%),laboratory(27.6%),indicationwithoutdruguse(17.5%),anddosingerrors(15.4%).PatientswithDMareat
increasedriskformedication-relatedproblems.HealthcareproviderstakingcareofHDpatientsshouldbeawareof
thisproblem,andeffortstoavoidorresolvemedication-relatedproblemsshouldbeundertakenatallHDclinics. Am
JKidneyDis 41:386-393.
© 2003bytheNationalKidneyFoundation,Inc.
INDEXWORDS:Hemodialysis(HD);medication-relatedproblem;riskfactor.
I
N THE UNITED STATES, health care system
medication-related problems cause signifi-
cant morbidity, mortality, and cost. Medication-
related problems are implicated in 16.1% of all
hospital admissions to an internal medicine ward.
1
Of these, 58.9% of admissions could definitely
or possibly be avoided. Once admitted to the
hospital, greater than 18% of patient deaths in
the internal medicine ward can be attributed to
one or more drugs,
2
and adverse drug events
contribute to more than 100,000 deaths annu-
ally.
3
The cost of medication-related problems on
the health care system is estimated to be in
excess of $177 billion.
4
Since the release of the
Institutes of Medicine report highlighting the
burden of medication errors in the United States,
issues of patient safety have become a priority on
the health care agenda.
5
Medication-related problems can be classified
into eight general categories: untreated indica-
tion (IWD), improper drug selection (WD), sub-
therapeutic dosage (UD), overdose (OD), ad-
verse drug reaction (ADR), drug interaction (DI),
failure to receive drug (FRD), and drug use
without indication (DWI).
6
At an ambulatory
clinic, risk factors for adverse drug events were
the following indicators: more than three concur-
rent disease states present, medication regimen
changed four or more times during the past 12
months, five or more medications in present drug
regimen, 12 or more medication doses per day,
history of noncompliance, and presence of drugs
that require therapeutic monitoring.
7
Risk in-
creased with more risk factors present. In another
study of critical care patients, impaired renal
function was a risk for adverse drug outcome.
8
Currently, there are approximately 350,000
patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) in
From the University of Missouri-Kansas City, School of
Pharmacy; Dialysis Clinic, Inc; Pfizer Clinical Education
Department; and Kidney Associates of Kansas City, Kansas
City, MO.
Received June 17, 2002; accepted in revised form August
14, 2002.
Address reprint requests to Harold J. Manley, PharmD,
Assistant Professor of Pharmacy Practice, University of
Missouri-Kansas City, 2411 Holmes M3-C19, Kansas City,
MO 64108. E-mail: manleyh@umkc.edu
© 2003 by the National Kidney Foundation, Inc.
0272-6386/03/4102-0014$35.00/0
doi:10.1053/ajkd.2003.50048
American Journal of Kidney Diseases, Vol41,No2(February),2003:pp386-393 386