378
Psychiatria Danubina, 2021; Vol. 33, No. 3, pp 378-385 https://doi.org/10.24869/psyd.2021.378 Review
© Medicinska naklada - Zagreb, Croatia
COVID-19 Forum: Transformation of Our World and Mental Health
ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO'S NEST:
THE CHRONICLES OF STIGMA AND A PROPOSED
SOCIO-COGNITIVE-EMOTIONAL-BEHAVIORAL MODEL
FOR UNDERSTANDING ITS GENESIS IN COVID-19
Kumari Rina
1
, Vikas Menon
2
& Susanta Kumar Padhy
1
1
Department of Psychiatry, All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India
2
Department of Psychiatry, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education & Research (JIPMER),
Puducherry, India
received: 5.1.2021; revised: 14.3.2021; accepted: 7.4.2021
SUMMARY
Stigma is a convoluted interaction between history, sociology, psychology, medicine, anthropology, and politics. Often, stigma is
inter-twined at cognitive-emotional-behavioral level with a socio-cultural-economic-political milieu and hence distinct from
prejudice, discrimination or, stereotypy. Stigma against diseases as a concept has evolved and has differed among various illnesses.
At this time of humanitarian crisis, it is prudent to understand the concept, elements and models of stigma to tackle stigma against
COVID-19 instrumentally. Stigma against COVID-19 can be partially extrapolated from various models described in psychiatry for
mental illness. We propose an integrated socio-cognitive-emotional-behavioral model of stigma to conceptualize and understand the
stigma against COVID-19, a matter of immense public health significance.
Key words: stigma – stigmatized - models of stigma - COVID-19 – pandemic - stigma in COVID-19
* * * * *
INTRODUCTION
From 1720-2020, COVID-19 is among the four
hardest-hitting pandemics in history of mankind
(Gupta 2020). Infectious diseases are the most
stigmatized illnesses (Earnshaw & Quinn 2013).
Stigma, prejudice, and discrimination associated with
infectious diseases have ravaged humanity. The word
stigma comes from Greek ‘steizen’ referred originally
to a mark or brand on slaves or traitors (Goffman
1963). At an individual level, the negative con-
sequences of stigma spawn into social ostracism,
diminished self-esteem, self-confidence and, self-
efficacy; feeling of shame, guilt and embarrassment,
precipitating or worsening of mental illness (like
anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder,
substance abuse, suicide rate), reduced quality of life,
influence healthcare-seeking decisions and behaviors;
participation and treatment adherence (Türközer &
Öngür 2020, Corrigan et al. 2014). They also govern
outcomes in terms of the availability of healthcare
services. It undermines the government’s efforts on
policies, legislation, jurisprudence and implementation
on a large scale and may prolong infection trans-
mission (Corrigan et al. 2014, Stangl et al. 2019).
Although stigma is overweighed by criticism, it might
have a beneficial and adaptive evolutionary role in
disease avoidance. The universal ‘unitary theory’ of
stigma is lacking (Smith 2002). Stigma, its various
elements, and models have been proposed in the
literature in the past.
CONCEPTUALIZING STIGMA
AND ITS ELEMENTS
The pioneering work of Erving Goffman, 1963 and
Allport, 1958, sprang research in stigma. Prejudice is
defined as “an aversive or hostile attitude toward a
person who belongs to a group, simply because he
belongs to that group, and is therefore presumed to
have the objectionable qualities ascribed to the group”
(Allport 1958). Their work portrayed negative atti-
tudes, discrimination, and biased treatment towards
disadvantaged groups. Crocker et al. 1998 emphasized
the ‘devaluation of the stigmatized individuals’ posses-
sing (or believed to possess) some attribute, or charac-
teristic conveying a social identity in a particular ‘so-
cial context’. Experts have cited three main compo-
nents of stigma. These are authoritarianism, fear and
exclusion, and benevolence (Corrigan & Miller 2004,
Brockington et al. 1993, Farina 1998). Thornicraft et
al. 2007, advocated three elements of stigma, as igno-
rance (problem of knowledge), prejudice (problem of
attitudes), and discrimination (problems of behavior).
Figure 1 conceptualizes stigma and its elements (Goff-
man 1963, LeBel 2008, Watson & River 2006,
Ritscher et al. 2003, Mak et al. 2008, Rössler et al.
2016).