Plantand Soil 171: 303-316, 1995.
© 1995 KluwerAcademicPublishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Effect of wastewater sludge on growth and heavy metal bioaccumulation of
two Salix species
Michel Labrecque, Traian I. Teodorescu and St6phane Daigle
lnstitut de Recherche en Biologie Wgdtale, Jardin Botanique de Montrdal, 4101 Sherbrooke Est, Montrdal,
Qudbec, Canada, HIX 2B2
Received2 May 1994.Accepted in revisedform3 October1994
Key words: bioavailability, fertilization, heavy metals, productivity, Salix, wastewater sludge
Abstract
Fast-growing tree species, such as willows, can benefit from sludge application. While sludges are good fertilizers,
they may contain heavy metals which could reduce productivity and cause environment risks. The aims of the
present research were to: i) determine the biomass production of Salix discolor Mtihl. and Salix viminalis L. when
supplied with various amounts of dried and pelleted sludge and ii) assess the uptake and accumulation of heavy
metals. Trials were carried out using unrooted cuttings that were planted in large plastic pots containing sandy
soil and grown outdoors for a 20-week period. Five doses of sludge were applied: the equivalents of 0 (TO), 40
(T1), 80 (T2), 120 (T3), 160 (T4) and 200 (T5) kg "available" N ha -l . Trees which received the highest dosage of
sludge showed the best growth. Stem biomass was significantly greater for S. viminalis which had received sludge
treatments. The relationship between the total biomass yield Y (g) and the rate of fertilization X (equivalent to kg
of "available" nitrogen provided per hectare) is linear. Regression equations of predicted biomass production were
established as follows: S. discolor, Y = 28.36 + 0.56X and S. viminalis, Y = 39.95 + 0.64X. For both species, the
greatest stem biomass per g of N applied was produced with treatments 4 and 5. Amounts of nitrogen per leaf
area (N/LA) and per dry leaf mass (N/DL) were higher for S. viminalis. The metal transfer coefficient did not vary
between the species but was significantly different for Cd and Zn. Plants were able to absorb Cd and Zn, but were
less able to absorb Ni, Hg, Cu, and Pb. It was concluded that the dried and pelleted sludge is a good fertilizer. S.
discolor and particularly S. viminalis can be used as filters for the purification of wastewater sludge as well as for
biomass production purposes.
Introduction
Wastewater sludges produced by sewage treatment
plants are a good source of macroelements and
microelements and generally contain a high quantity
of organic matter. Their application in agriculture and
in silviculture translates into improved soil fertility.
Sludges also help maintain soil structure, soil water-
holding ability, soil cation exchange capacity, and soil
biological activity (Giroux and Tabi, 1990).
Although the recycling of sludge is an attractive
alternative, its use often brings about certain risks to
the environment caused by accumulation of heavy met-
als and organic compounds and potential contamina-
tion from pathogenic organisms. In Quebec (Canada),
standards have been set to establish acceptable levels
of these contaminants in the sludge and in fertilized
soils (MENVIQ, MAPAQ, 1991). The standards take
into account only the total quantity of metals in the
soil. In order to increase accuracy and reduce envi-
ronmental risks, an evaluation of the bioavailability
of metals to the plants and the heavy metal content
in soil solutions and ground water is necessary. For
this evaluation, assessment of the degree of solubility
of metals in the water is important (Petruzzelli et al.,
1985; Petruzzelli, 1989).
High metal content in agricultural crops is not desir-
able and is potentially dangerous. For trees, a higher
metal content is acceptable as long as normal phys-
iological activity is not affected. Generally, natural