Anatomical Sciences Education OCTOBER 2018 Anatomical Sciences Education 0:1–9 (2018)
Guided Hands-On Activities Can Improve Student Learning in
a Lecture-Based Qualitative Biomechanics Course
Robert D. Catena,
1
* Kira J. Carbonneau
2
1
Kinesiology Program, College of Education, Washington State University, Pullman, Washington
2
Educational Psychology Program, College of Education, Washington State University, Pullman, Washington
A qualitative biomechanics (functional anatomy) course is a typical course in kinesiology
curriculum. Most evidence suggests that biomechanics learning could be improved with
the inclusion of laboratory experiences. However, implementing laboratories into biome-
chanics curriculum is difficult due to cost and time constraints. This study was conducted
to evaluate whether hands-on activities in lecture improve qualitative biomechanics learn-
ing. A lecture format was compared to the same course with guided and unguided hands-
on activities included during lecture. Test performance and student evaluations were
compared between lecture formats to determine if hands-on experiences improve learning.
The hands-on group performed better on the same test questions and they evaluated their
overall course activities as beneficial to their learning. The findings suggest that guided
hands-on experiences may improve learning compared to unguided activities. The hands-
on experiences seem to provide an embodied cognitive learning experience, facilitating
retention of learned material through three-dimensional and tactile mental representa-
tions. Findings from this research are currently shaping how biomechanics is taught to
students at this university and could at other universities as well. Anat Sci Educ 0: 1–9.
© 2018 American Association of Anatomists.
Key words: gross anatomy education; undergraduate education; musculoskeletal anatomy;
kinesiology education; anatomy laboratory; hands-on science; embodied cognition;
guidance
INTRODUCTION
Kinesiology is the study of human movement. Human anatomy
is a foundational course, and often one of the first classes for
an undergraduate kinesiology major. Kinesiology was the 33rd
most popular undergraduate degree granted in the US in 2014,
with almost 24,000 degrees granted that year (USDE, 2014).
Biomechanics is typically one of four or five core courses that
all kinesiology students are required to take in their degree.
However, biomechanics courses tend to be different from other
kinesiology courses, and more challenging to some students,
because of the application of physics principles to the human
body to understand the relationship between form and func-
tion (Knudson et al., 2009; Shofler et al., 2015).
Biomechanics melds functional musculoskeletal anatomy
with mechanical physics (Knudson, 2003). It builds off mus-
cle actions learned in gross anatomy to determine real-world
muscle use. It teaches students to simultaneously consider a
number of anatomical (center of rotation, force-length relation-
ships, force–velocity relationships, muscle moment arm, struc-
tural impediments to motion), and external (gravity, inertia,
fluid forces) factors that impact movement to understand how
muscle are used during functional activities. More than 90% of
biomechanics courses have anatomy, and only 20% have phys-
ics, as prerequisite courses (Hamill, 2007). However, biome-
chanics instructors are typically trained in either kinesiology or
mechanical engineering. Current imbalance between anatomy
and physics concepts, related to the instructor’s background,
has led to concerns about the overemphasis of one of these over
the other in biomechanics courses (Knudsen, 2003). In addition,
biomechanics courses tend to be upper division courses and
so student retention of pre-requisite musculoskeletal anatomy
knowledge may suffer from the length of time since a lower
division anatomy course (Sinclair, 1965; Semb and Ellis, 1994).
Kinesiology undergraduate programs will typically offer
one upper-division biomechanics course, but some programs
© 2018 American Association of Anatomists
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
*Correspondence to: Dr. Robert D. Catena, Kinesiology Program,
Washington State University 113F Smith Gym, Pullman, WA, 99164-
1410. USA. E-mail: robert.catena@wsu.edu
Additional supporting information can be viewed in the online version
of this article.
Received 26 April 2018; Revised 17 August 2018; Accepted 1
September 2018.
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com).
DOI 10.1002/ase.1832