Soil Science Society of America Journal
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 81:1621–1628
doi:10.2136/sssaj2017.04.0134
Received 27 Apr. 2017.
Accepted 12 Sep. 2017.
*Corresponding author: (qiangzhuuf@gmail.com).
© Soil Science Society of America, 5585 Guilford Rd., Madison WI 53711 USA. All Rights reserved.
Comparing Extractants for Calibrating Potassium Rates
for Tomato Grown on a Calcareous Soil
Nutrient Management & Soil & Plant Analysis
Potassium application rates based on a reliable soil testing method are critical
for maximizing crop yields and minimizing fertilizer costs. Vegetables grown
on calcareous soils, however, have no soil test potassium (STK) interpretations
in Florida. Therefore, the objectives of this study were to compare Mehlich-3,
ammonium bicarbonate-DTPA (AB-DTPA), and water to estimate K availability
and calibrate K rates for tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) grown on a calcare-
ous soil. The experiment was conducted during the winter seasons of 2014 and
2015. Potassium fertilizers were applied through preplant dry fertilizer and drip
fertigation at total rate of 0, 56, 93, 149, 186, and 223 kg K ha
–1
. Regression
models were performed to calibrate K rates by tomato relative yield with total
K input (initial STK plus full-season K rate). Concentrations of STK were sig-
nifcantly correlated among the three extractants and the highest correlation
occurred between Mehlich-3 and AB-DTPA. Due to the high variability, water
was ineffective to estimate K availability. Signifcantly linear relationships were
found between total K uptake (TKU) and total K inputs using both Mehlich-3
extracted K (Mehlich-3-K) and AB-DTPA-K. The low STK levels were predicted
from 85 to 150 and 70 to 120 mg K kg
–1
and the corresponding required K
rates ranged from 307 to 151 and 271 to 151 kg K ha
–1
using Mehlich-3-K and
AB-DTPA-K, respectively. Thus, both Mehlich-3 and AB-DTPA can be used to
predict K availability and K rates needed to produce optimal marketable yield
for tomato grown on calcareous soils in Florida.
Abbreviations: AB-DTPA, ammonium bicarbonate-diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid;
DAPF, days after preplant fertilization; STK, soil test potassium; TKU, total potassium
uptake; TSMY, total season marketable yield.
S
oil testing is used to assess potential availability of soil nutrients to crops.
In soil testing, a universal extractant is the ideal option for extracting both
macronutrients and micronutrients with a single extraction solution ( Jones,
1990). Soil test interpretation usually includes three categories: low, medium, and
high, at which 50 to 75%, 75 to 100%, and at or near 100% of crop yield potential
can be expected, respectively, without addition of nutrients (Savoy, 2013). Using
this type of rating scale, there are dramatic changes in rates of fertilizer recom-
mendations if the soil test values are near the boundaries of adjacent ratings. Such
boundary effect might be circumvented by the continuous function curves to cal-
culate the required fertilizer with soil test results (Savoy, 2013). Potassium fertilizer
recommendations based on preplant soil test are critical in ensuring crop yield and
quality and minimizing fertilizer costs (Ozores-Hampton et al., 2012b). Soil K is
typically divided into four forms with increasing plant availability: mineral, non-
exchangeable, exchangeable, and soluble K (Havlin et al., 2014). Plants absorb K
mostly from the soil solution, which is buffered by exchangeable K and ultimately
by nonexchangeable forms (Wang et al., 2010).
Adopting a soil test method to estimate K fertilizer requirements is an impor-
tant component of nutrient management for vegetables. Currently, there are two
Qiang Zhu*
Monica Ozores-Hampton
Southwest Florida Research and
Education Center
Univ. of Florida
2685 State Road 29 N
Immokalee, FL 34142
Yuncong C. Li
Tropical Research and Education Center
Univ. of Florida
18905 SW 280th Street
Homestead, FL 33031
Rao S. Mylavarapu
Soil and Water Sciences Dep.
Univ. of Florida
2181 McCarty Hall
Gainesville, FL 32611
Core Ideas
• Water was ineffective to estimate K
availability in calcareous soils in Florida.
• Both Mehlich-3 and AB-DTPA can
be used to calibrate K rates in
calcareous soils.
• High K level was above 213 and
183 mg kg
–1
with Mehlich-3 and AB-
DTPA, respectively.
Published online January 4, 2018