Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Cities
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/cities
Affordable housing in border cities: The work of Esperanza
de Mexico in Tijuana
Mauricio Soto-Rubio
⁎
, Vanessa Hausman
Faculty of Environmental Design, School of Architecture, University of Calgary, Professional Faculties Building, Room 2182, 2500 University Drive NW, Calgary, AB T2N
1N4, Canada
ABSTRACT
This paper explores the socio-economic conditions that produce the lack of affordable housing in cities along the U.S.-Mexico border and describes various efforts to
tackle this issue. Specifically, the paper evaluates publicly funded initiatives such as Casas Urbi and Homex, privately funded projects, as well as community based
initiatives such as the work of the non-profit organization Fundación Esperanza de Mexico in the city of Tijuana. The paper interrogates the use of self-build
construction systems, volunteer support, community empowerment, ecological programs, and affordable financing as a framework for future affordable housing
developments in the area.
1. Introduction
In cities along the southern part of the U.S-Mexico border, the
proliferation of manufacturing plants commonly known as maquiladoras
has generated increased working opportunities, the rapid growth in the
population, demographic changes, and the expansion of the city. This
has resulted in the lack of sufficient adequate and affordable housing
options, with many immigrants seeking informal housing that even-
tually becomes permanent. In response, several government agencies,
private developers as well as non-profit organizations have im-
plemented different strategies to develop affordable housing options.
Among these are Casas Homex, Urbi, Geo, privately funded self-help
projects, as well as the work of the non-profit organization Fundación
Esperanza the Mexico (FEM).
1.1. Tijuana, a Changing City
The demand for affordable housing in Tijuana drastically increased
in the 1960s, when manufacturing companies started building plants
along the U.S.-Mexico border (Davis & Cairns, 2003:239). This eco-
nomic strategy was part of the original free-trade zone agreement be-
tween the two countries and it was intended to reduce Mexican un-
employment, to stimulate industrial development with foreign
investment, to improve Mexico's commercial deficit with the U.S., and
to encourage U.S.-Mexico joint business ventures (Williams & Homedes,
2001:321). However, the rapid increase in the number of plants also
generated important socio-economic and environmental issues in both
countries. The northern half of Mexico was deliberately targeted for
factories, with 735 manufacturing plants in Tijuana alone in 2001
(Williams & Homedes, 2001:321). This resulted in a massive growth of
the local economy but it also led to a major decline of Mexico's interior
market (Davis & Cairns, 2003:242). Perhaps more significantly, the
limited resources of the area and the growth of the population resulted
in the lack of sufficient affordable housing. In an effort to provide so-
lutions, the Mexican government subsidized the completion of many
settlements for low-income families. Unfortunately, these colonies were
often isolated and lacked basic utilities such as water, sewage, elec-
tricity, or paved roads. In addition, the environmental impact in the city
included increased air and water pollution that affected the public
health of its inhabitants. No planning was done to support the required
infrastructure for the immense industrial growth, releasing toxic sub-
stances from the manufacturing plants into the sewage systems
(Williams & Homedes, 2001:6). Tijuana's Northern twin city, San Diego,
also experienced important environmental issues, with “drinking water
being hauled or acquired via shallow, dug wells that quickly become
tainted by human waste, pesticide runoff, or heavy metals present in
the surrounding soil” (Davis & Cairns, 2003:242). Similar issues con-
tinued along the El Paso-Juarez border, with an estimated 1.5 million
U.S. residents living in informal housing developments (Davis & Cairns,
2003:243).
For the last 60 years, the Mexican government has continued to look
for alternatives to address the lack of affordable housing in border ci-
ties. These include large-scale top-down publicly funded initiatives as
well as privately financed self-help affordable housing projects. In ad-
dition, local non-profit organizations have proliferated in the area and
implemented bottom-up strategies to work together with communities
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2018.12.016
Received 3 May 2018; Received in revised form 6 December 2018; Accepted 17 December 2018
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: mauricio.sotorubio@ucalgary.ca (M. Soto-Rubio).
Cities 88 (2019) 76–82
0264-2751/ © 2018 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
T