Strategies for CT tissue segmentation for Monte Carlo calculations
in nuclear medicine dosimetry
P. E. N. Braad
a)
and T. Andersen
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Odense University Hospital, Sdr. Boulevard 29,
Odense C DK-5000, Denmark
S. B. Hansen
Department of Nuclear Medicine and PET-Centre, Aarhus University Hospital, Nørrebrogade 44,
Aarhus C DK-8000, Denmark
P. F. Høilund-Carlsen
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Odense University Hospital, Sdr. Boulevard 29,
Odense C DK-5000, Denmark
(Received 4 January 2016; revised 22 September 2016; accepted for publication 22 October 2016;
published 15 November 2016)
Purpose: CT images are used for patient specific Monte Carlo treatment planning in radionuclide
therapy. The authors investigated the impact of tissue classification, CT image segmentation, and CT
errors on Monte Carlo calculated absorbed dose estimates in nuclear medicine.
Methods: CT errors as a function of patient size, CT reconstruction, and tube current modulation
methods were assessed in a phantom experiment on a clinical CT system. The impact of tissue
segmentation methods and CT number variations on EGSnrc Monte Carlo calculated absorbed dose
distributions was assessed for
99m
Tc and
131
I in the ICRP/ICRU male phantom and in a patient
PET/CT-scanned with
124
I prior to radioiodine therapy.
Results: CT number variations <20 HU were obtained for whole-body CT examinations at effective
CT doses ∼2 mSv. Monte Carlo calculated absorbed doses depended on both the number of media
types and accurate calibration of the CT number-to-density conversion ramp. Tissue segmentation by
a 13-tissue CT conversion ramp, calibrated by a stoichiometric method, resulted in low (<4%) dose
errors in selected organs for both isotopes.
Conclusions: A calibrated CT scanner specific conversion ramp is required for accurate patient
specific dosimetry in nuclear medicine. Accurate dosimetry was obtained with a 13-tissue ramp
that included five different bone types.
C
2016 American Association of Physicists in Medicine.
[http://dx.doi.org/10.1118/1.4967267]
Key words: radionuclide therapy, nuclear medicine, CT, dosimetry, Monte Carlo, PET/CT,
SPECT/CT
1. INTRODUCTION
In recent years, numerous research groups have explored the
potential and feasibility of improving clinical dosimetry in
nuclear medicine (NM) by using Monte Carlo (MC) methods
for dose calculations.
1–6
Most NM clinical dosimetry studies
are based on the simple S-value formalism,
7
where absorbed
doses are calculated from patient specific activity distribu-
tions and tabulated S-values. The errors of internal dosimetry
calculations for diagnostic or therapeutic studies with current
conventional methods may be as large as 30%–100% or even
higher.
8
Large dose errors limit the value of dosimetry and may
indirectly be responsible for an inefficient and non-optimal use
of targeted radionuclide therapies (TRTs) in clinical cancer
treatments. Radioiodine therapy (RAIT) of thyroid cancer
9
is
an example of a therapeutic approach with growing interest in
patient specific treatment planning. The increased availability
of
124
I has raised the interest in PET-based pre-RAIT dosim-
etry and several clinical studies are currently investigating the
potential of this approach.
10–12
Likewise, it has been argued in
a recent study
13
that radiation doses to patients from diagnostic
radiopharmaceuticals in NM may better be evaluated in real
patients by MC methods rather than from tabulated S-values
calculated in reference phantoms.
MC dose calculations in NM depend on the availability
of combined PET and CT or SPECT and CT information.
The NM scans provide information on the biodistribution of
radionuclides in the patient and CT numbers provide detailed
information on the radiological properties of the tissues.
3,14
Before MC methods can be used for routine calculations of
patient specific dose estimates, it is pivotal that all technical
aspects in the calculations are evaluated and optimized care-
fully in realistic anthropomorphic phantom experiments. One
aspect that has only received limited attention is the use of
CT for tissue segmentation. CT information is required to
calculate patient specific physical cross-sections for the MC
simulation, and the accuracy of CT numbers therefore has a
direct impact on the accuracy of dose calculations.
15,16
Clinical dosimetry studies often consider density variations
but neglect tissue composition variations by only using water
cross-sections.
3,17–20
For megavoltage external photon beam
radiotherapy (EBRT), the differences in atomic compositions
6507 Med. Phys. 43 (12), December 2016 0094-2405/2016/43(12)/6507/10/$30.00 © 2016 Am. Assoc. Phys. Med. 6507