IEEE Wireless Communications • December 2014 153 1536-1284/14/$25.00 © 2014 IEEE
Kui Ren is with the State
University of New York at
Buffalo.
Qian Wang is with
Wuhan University.
Di Ma is with the
University of Michigan,
Dearborn.
Xiaohua Jia is with City
University of Hong Kong.
A CCEPTED FROM O PEN C ALL
INTRODUCTION
Near-Field Communication (NFC) is an emerg-
ing wireless technology designed for low-power
communication between devices within close
proximity (e.g. a few centimeters) [1]. The close
communication range, as a result of fast decay-
ing magnetic induction between the antennas of
NFC transmitter and receiver, is a distinctive
trait of NFC and brings several key advantages.
First, due to the physical collocation of the
transmitter/receiver, NFC does not require cum-
bersome network configuration and can be used
as out-of-band channels for secure device pairing
without resorting to a Public Key Infrastructure
(PKI) or trusted third parties. Second, it offers a
natural, physical protection against various
attacks, particularly malicious eavesdropping.
Due to these silent features, NFC is expected to
revolutionize a range of mobile applications,
from contactless payment and ticketing access
control, to peripheral pairing for smart devices.
It is estimated that the NFC market will grow to
34 billion by 2016.
However, the widespread use of NFC is hin-
dered by the fact that only a limited number of
smartphone/tablet platforms have built-in NFC
chipsets. Moreover, in order to support NFC on
the existing industrial infrastructure like POS
terminals, it typically requires costly hardware
and software upgrades, due to the need for addi-
tional NFC chipsets and radio stack. As of 2012,
it is estimated that only three to five percent of
smartphones worldwide and 12 percent of smart-
phones in the U.S. have NFC support. For
instance, the popular iPhone has no NFC sup-
port. Moreover, while NFC does not incorporate
any security at the physical or MAC layers by
assuming that the extremely short range of com-
munication in itself has offered a degree of phys-
ical protection, several recent findings have
brought the security of NFC into question.
Account details of Google Wallet could easily be
hacked into and changed. In [2] the eavesdrop-
ping distance of NFC is empirically measured to
be 30 cm using an oscilloscope. Recent experi-
mental studies shows that, with a specially
designed portable NFC sniffer, it is possible to
eavesdrop NFC transmissions from up to 240 cm
away, which is at least an order of magnitude
further than the intended NFC communication
distance. These results have seriously challenged
the general perception that NFC is immune to
eavesdropping. Recently, the NFC forum pro-
posed that NFCIP-1 and NFC-SEC-01 specifica-
tions adopt the Diffie-Hellman key exchange
protocol to enhance data confidentiality. Howev-
er, most existing NFC applications are designed
for short-duration rapid data exchange, and the
lengthy key exchange process might dominate
the entire NFC communication session, compro-
mising the user experience.
Recently, great interest has been aroused in
the practicality and security enhancement of
KUI REN, QIAN W ANG, DI MA, AND XIAOHUA JIA
ABSTRACT
As an emerging advanced short-range com-
munication technology, near field communica-
tion (NFC) is undergoing a fast rate of expansion
with many promising benefits including low
power, small size, and peer-to-peer communica-
tion, without incurring complex network configu-
ration overhead. However, current NFC
technologies suffer from one practical limitation:
almost all NFC-enabled applications require
built-in NFC chipsets, and as a result such low
levels of penetration of NFC hardware has
stymied its applications on most mobile devices
in the market, for example, smartphone and
tablet platforms. In addition, from the security
perspective the confidentiality of the transmitted
data has not been satisfactorily addressed by cur-
rent NFC technologies, which do not incorpo-
rate any security at the physical or MAC layers
by assuming that the extremely short range of
communication itself has offered a degree of
protection physically.
Therefore, great interest has been aroused in
the practicality and security enhancement of
NFC technologies. In this article we discuss alter-
native NFC technologies, with an emphasis on
barcode-based NFC and acoustics-based NFC,
which are compatible with legacy devices and
existing infrastructure and can provide a high
level of security guarantee. Following a brief
overview of barcode-based and acoustics-based
short-range communications respectively, for
each technology we present the major technical
hurdles to be overcome and the state-of-the-art,
and finally offer a vision of the future research
issues on these two promising technologies.
S ECURING E MERGING S HORT R ANGE W IRELESS
C OMMUNICATIONS : T HE S TATE OF THE A RT