Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Applied Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/apenergy
Impact of battery technological progress on electricity arbitrage: An
application to the Iberian market
Ángel Arcos-Vargas
⁎
, David Canca, Fernando Núñez
School of Engineering, Department of Industrial Engineering and Management Science, University of Seville, Spain
HIGHLIGHTS
•
A Mixed-Integer Linear Programming arbitrage model has been proposed.
•
Given hourly electricity prices, the optimal battery configuration is obtained.
•
Li-Ion arbitrage will be profitable after 2024, thanks to technological progress.
•
Public Research Funds should encourage research aimed at reducing battery costs.
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Electricity markets
Arbitrage business
BESS
Mixed-integer programming
Technological progress
ABSTRACT
Recent technological advances in power electronics and electrical storage have increased interest in the arbitrage
business based on Battery Energy Storage Systems. With this objective, the present work develops a Mixed-
Integer Linear Programming model for obtaining optimal electricity sale\purchase strategies with batteries. For
each configuration (battery size /inverter size), the model provides an optimal trading strategy. Using this
strategy for different configurations and with the current market prices, some financial indicators are calculated
in order to select the optimal configuration. Finally, our analysis considers the significant technological progress
that has occurred in recent years, the effects on profitability of a reduction in the battery cost, and of an im-
provement both in the round-trip efficiency and in the battery's lifetime (in terms of the number of cycles). The
results indicate that, with current technology, the optimal inverter size for a 10 MWh battery is 3 MW, although,
if technological progress continues at the current rate, the arbitrage of electricity by using batteries is expected to
be viable from 2024 onwards. Additionally, the effects that different technological improvements (cost, useful
life and losses) will have on profitability are calculated,; for example, it is observed that an improvement of 1.6%
of the round-trip efficiency and an increase of 1000 life cycles will provide an average increase of 16,000 € and
75,000 €, respectively, in terms of Net Present Value.
1. Introduction
The electrical system configuration, since its creation in the 19th
century, has been responsible for ensuring a continuing balance be-
tween electricity supply and demand. On the one hand, demand can
present great variations associated with the time of day, season, tem-
perature or economic activity. On the other hand, supply can be man-
ageable (thermal plants), unmanageable (hydraulic, wind, etc.) or dif-
ficult to regulate (nuclear). In those countries where equilibrium is
reached by market mechanisms, the daily market (day ahead) gets
hourly prices, which are adjusted by technical restrictions (restricted
market) due to the fact that the system is not an ideal network, as well
as by variations in demand and supply in the short term (intra-day
market), thereby ensuring the appropriate functioning of the system
through the provision of ancillary services. These price variations send
signals to the agents to modulate their demand or orient their supply, as
appropriate.
In recent years, concerns for the environment have introduced
changes in production technologies controlled by governments, in-
creasing the contribution of renewable sources which, being un-
manageable, have increased price volatility. These have led to negative
prices at times, making the demand management or arbitrage through
storage even more attractive. On the other hand, there has been an
important technological change, with the appearance of several tech-
nologies that can operate the market, obtaining an economic benefit
and providing stability and reliability to the system.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2019.114273
Received 28 August 2019; Received in revised form 25 November 2019; Accepted 27 November 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: aarcos@us.es (Á. Arcos-Vargas).
Applied Energy 260 (2020) 114273
0306-2619/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T