Vol.:(0123456789) 1 3
International Journal of Geosynthetics and Ground Engineering (2021) 7:44
https://doi.org/10.1007/s40891-021-00282-x
ORIGINAL PAPER
Prediction of Ultimate Bearing Capacity of Aggregate Pier Reinforced
Clay Using Machine Learning
Sharad Dadhich
1
· Jitendra Kumar Sharma
1
· Madhav Madhira
2,3
Received: 4 January 2021 / Accepted: 28 April 2021 / Published online: 30 May 2021
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2021
Abstract
Aggregate piers are extensively in use for increasing bearing pressure and diminish settlement under the footing. The ulti-
mate bearing capacity of aggregate pier reinforced clay is majorly afected by soil strength (c
u
), area replacement ratio (a
r
)
of piles, geometry, and slenderness ratio (λ) of piles. Various prediction models have been proposed to predict the ultimate
bearing capacity of aggregate piers. However, existing models have shown a broad range of bias, variation, errors, and as
such they are unsuitable for practical design. In this study, machine learning algorithms (linear and non-linear regression) and
Artifcial neural networks (ANNs) were performed using feld loading test results to predict the ultimate bearing capacity of
ground reinforced by aggregate piers. Sensitivity analysis was conducted to identify the infuence of input variables. To fulfl
this objective, 37 test results were used for training and testing of diferent models and compared with each other based on
statistical parameters (mean absolute error, root mean squared error, and r
2
-score). Random Forest Regression model came
out to be the best suitable for prediction of ultimate bearing capacity with minimum mean absolute error (MAE = 38.93 kPa)
and r
2
-score equal to 0.98.
Keywords Aggregate pier · Ultimate bearing capacity · Machine learning · Artifcial neural networks · Sensitivity analysis
Introduction
Soft soils, such as clays and silts, have low strength and high
compressibility. Thus, soft soils are vulnerable to construc-
tion activities at moderate loads and need ground improve-
ment before construction. Various ground improvement
techniques such as soil-stabilization, pre-loading with PVDs,
and stone columns/granular piles have been used extensively
in small to medium projects. Recently, aggregate piers are
being used extensively to increase bearing capacity and
reduce settlement and lateral displacements under founda-
tion. Aggregate piers act as vertical drains and accelerate
the consolidation of surrounding soft soil. The prediction of
the altered or modifed ground’s ultimate bearing capacity
is an essential task for a proper design [1]. Since the early
1970s, many researchers had aimed to develop a methodol-
ogy based on elastic and plastic theories [2], cavity expan-
sion theory [3, 4], numerical [5, 6], and empirical methods
[7, 8]. Predictive models were developed continuously and
modifed. Laboratory and feld tests on the aggregate piers
had been performed to investigate the failure mechanisms,
and their ultimate bearing capacity evaluated [9–12]. Ambily
and Gandhi [13] presented a detailed experimental study
carried out on the behaviour of single and group of stone
columns, and results from the study were compared with the
fnite element analysis model. Hanna et al. [14] presented
a numerical model to simulate single and group of stone-
column performance in soft soils. Mohanty and Samantha
[15] studied the behaviour of stone columns in the laboratory
and proposed a numerical study. Algin and Gumus [16] pre-
sented 3D numerical modelling considering the installation
efect. Etezad et al. [17] developed an analytical model to
predict soft soil bearing capacity reinforced with stone-col-
umn and validated it via numerical and experimental result.
In the early nineties, artifcial intelligence (AI), because
of its capability and versatility, came in to picture to solve
several critical civil engineering problems. Artifcial neural
network (ANN) is a machine learning algorithm that simu-
lates the working of personage brain by automation of data
mining and data acquisition. Many researchers extensively
used ANN to obtain solutions for many complex problems.
Literature studies revealed that ANN had been used for
Extended author information available on the last page of the article