ORIGINAL CONTRIBUTION
Impact of Cry1Ab toxin expression on the non-target insects
dwelling on maize plants
O. Habus ˇ tova ´
1
, P. Dolez ˇal
1,2
, L. Spitzer
1,2
, Z. Svobodova ´
1,2
, H. Hussein
1
& F. Sehnal
1,2
1 Biology Centre ASCR, Entomological Institute, C
ˇ
eske ´ Bude ˇ jovice, Czech Republic
2 Faculty of Science, University of South Bohemia, C
ˇ
eske ´ Bude ˇ jovice, Czech Republic
Keywords
aphids, environmental risk assessment,
European corn borer, genetically modified
crops, pirate bugs, thrips
Correspondence
Oxana Habus ˇ tova ´ (corresponding author),
Biology Centre AS CR, Entomological Institute,
Branis ˇ ovska ´ 31, 370 05 C
ˇ
eske ´ Bude ˇ jovice,
Czech Republic.
E-mail: habustova@entu.cas.cz
Received: January 25, 2012; accepted: July 27,
2012.
doi: 10.1111/jen.12004
Abstract
The effect of transgenic maize MON810 (Bt maize) on the diversity and
abundance of plant-dwelling insects was tested under field conditions in
southern Bohemia (coordinates 48°N, 14ºE, 384 m a.s.l.) for three succes-
sive years. The experiment was carried out on 10 0.5-ha plots of which
five were seeded with the Bt maize and five with the non–Bt parental cul-
tivar. The content of Bt toxin (Cry1Ab) was measured in plant tissues with
a commercial ELISA kit. Randomly chosen plants (10 per plot) were taken
from the field during the vegetation period in about 2-week intervals and
thoroughly examined in the laboratory. Collected insects were identified
and their counts were statistically analysed with CANOCO with respect to
the Bt toxin, developmental stage of maize and the year of cultivation. No
significant effect of Bt maize on the plant-dwelling non-target insects was
detected. Correlation between the number of plants and detected insect
diversity revealed that inspection of 20 plants (four per each of five plots)
provided data reliable at 95% probability level; six plants per plot were
sufficient for the analysis of aphids, thrips and Orius bugs.
Introduction
Insect pests are often the major cause of yield losses in
agricultural crops. The most important pest of maize
in Europe, the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis
(Hbn.) (Lepidoptera: Crambicidae), causes yield losses
of 5–30% (Meissle et al. 2010). Pest management cur-
rently relies on the applications of insecticides but
their use often brings about ecological damage owing
to lethality to the non-target species, insecticide accu-
mulation in the soil, contamination of waters and
sometimes the presence of insecticide residues in the
harvested crops. Excessive use of insecticides may
cause outbreaks of secondary pests by eliminating
their natural enemies and altering trophic relation-
ships in the ecosystem. In spite of this potential dan-
ger, European corn borer is often controlled with
broad-spectrum insecticides including pyrethroids and
organophosphates that are cheap, suppress several
arthropod pests simultaneously, and their use has a
long tradition.
The deployment of genetically modified (GM)
crops, which express a toxin targeted to specific herbi-
vores, is regarded as a suitable alternative to the pesti-
cide use (Sharma et al. 2004; Romeis et al. 2006;
Meissle et al. 2011). Evaluation of the risks and bene-
fits of the GM crops has been in the focus of attention
since their commercialization (Ferber 1999) but some
concerns remain, particularly about possible environ-
mental side effects (Firbank et al. 2005). In response
to the fear of possible unwanted effect, EU authorities
will demand post-market environmental monitoring
(PMEM). We examined environmental impact of the
GM maize event MON810 that was cultivated on the
same plots for 3 years. Our data will be used in the
development of PMEM methodology.
MON810 maize has been genetically engineered to
express the insecticidal protein Cry1Ab, one of the
toxins produced by the bacterium Bacillus thuringien-
sis. Different strains of B. thuringiensis produce differ-
ent kinds of the Cry proteins, called Bt toxins, that act
specifically against certain insect groups. Thus, it is
© 2012 Blackwell Verlag, GmbH 1
J. Appl. Entomol.