RESEARCH
70 | REPRINTED FROM AJGP VOL. 49, NO. 1–2, JAN–FEB 2020 © The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners 2020
Mikhaila Lazanyi, Sonia R Grover
Background and objective
Heavy menstrual bleeding (HMB) in
adolecents is predominantly related to an
immature hypothalamic–pituitary–ovarian
axis. Structural causes in this population
are extremely rare; therefore, pelvic
ultrasonography is not required as a first-
line investigation. Anecdotally, it has been
observed that pelvic ultrasounds of
adolescents with HMB are normal and
do not change clinical care. The aim of
this study was to analyse all female
patients aged ≤18 years who were
referred to a tertiary paediatric hospital
for HMB over a 12-month period.
Method
Medical records were reviewed to
determine if pelvic ultrasonography was
ordered during the diagnostic process
and whether the imaging altered
management.
Results
No pelvic ultrasounds ordered for
adolescents with HMB altered clinical
management. General practitioners (GP)
were the most likely to refer patients to
the tertiary paediatric hospital and to
order pelvic ultrasonography, likely
reflecting that most female adolescents
are seen by a GP within the community.
Discussion
Providing clinical updates and ongoing
education to health professionals
managing female adolescent patients
is recommended.
THE COMPLEXITY OF tests, treatments and
procedures in modern medicine is at an
unprecedented level. Unnecessary practices
and frequent and invasive investigations
are potentially costly to the healthcare
system, may divert away from effective
care and can potentially expose the patient
to undue risk of harm, emotional stress or
personal financial costs.
1
Paediatric and adolescent gynaecology
is a unique sub-speciality that falls under
the domain of general practitioners
(GPs), gynaecologists, paediatricians and
emergency physicians. During medical
training, this sub-speciality is frequently
not covered in depth, and exposure to
this area can be limited post-fellowship.
It has been shown that history taking and
diagnostic ordering for adolescent females
presenting with heavy menstrual bleeding
(HMB) is inconsistent and inadequate.
2
This has been suggested to contribute
to clinicians ordering investigations
overcautiously. The resultant increase in
patient (and parental) anxiety, which is not
uncommon in this patient demographic, is
considerable.
Abnormal uterine bleeding (AUB)
refers to any variation from a normal
menstrual cycle. It includes HMB and
irregular bleeding, which together
account for up to half of adolescent
gynaecology visits.
3
HMB in this age
group is almost invariably due to an
immature hypothalamic–pituitary–ovarian
axis, which is reflective of the pubertal
transition. The physiological maturation
of this axis can persist for up to 5–8 years
post-menarche.
4,5
This differs from the
causes and management of HMB in older
women of reproductive age, which are
more likely to be related to structural
causes. A retrospective review of 230
adolescents at a paediatric hospital
in Canada showed that 67.8% of all
patients referred with AUB had pelvic
ultrasonography performed as part of
their initial workup, and ‘no patient had
a change in her AUB management due
to ultrasound findings’.
6
Unfortunately,
unnecessary ordering of pelvic
ultrasonography for AUB in adolescent
females is common.
In Australia, 14.9% of GP encounters
with female patients aged <25 years
are for women’s health problems,
compared with 12% for women of any
age.
7
The majority of these patients are
managed solely by GPs, with referral
to a gynaecologist occurring at a rate
of 0.8 per 100 GP–female patient
encounters.
8
In Victoria, Tasmania and
southern New South Wales, a significant
proportion of adolescent females referred
to a gynaecologist are seen at the Royal
Children’s Hospital (RCH).
This study was designed to review all
new referrals to gynaecology for female
adolescents with HMB from 1 January
2017 to 31 December 2017, to identify
whether or not pelvic ultrasonography had
been arranged prior to a referral. It was
hypothesised that pelvic ultrasonography
was frequently being ordered in the
Reducing unnecessary investigations
in adolescent gynaecology
The utility of pelvic ultrasonography for adolescents
presenting with heavy menstrual bleeding