Clinical findings in 10 foals with bacterial meningoencephalitis
J. VIU, L. MONREAL, E. JOSE-CUNILLERAS, C. CESARINI, S. AÑOR
†
and L. ARMENGOU*
Servei de Medicina Interna Equina, Facultat de Veterinària, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
†
Servei de Neurologia i Neurocirurgia, Facultat de Veterinària, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
*Correspondence email: lara.armengou@uab.es; Received: 10.01.11; Accepted: 26.07.11
Summary
Reasons for performing the study: Bacterial meningoencephalitis is a severe complication in septic foals and there is scarce and often unclear information
in the equine literature.
Objectives: To report the most frequent clinical signs, clinicopathological findings, causative agents, treatments given and outcome of a group of foals with
confirmed bacterial meningoencephalitis.
Methods: Foals aged <6 months of age admitted to the Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona (2004–2009) with confirmed bacterial meningoencephalitis
were retrospectively included in the study. Diagnosis of bacterial meningoencephalitis was made by cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) culture, CSF analysis consistent
with bacterial infection, observation of bacteria in CSF cytology or post mortem confirmation.
Results: Nine neonates and one 5-month-old foal were included. The most frequently observed clinical signs were alterations in mental status (10/10),
recumbency (8/10), weakness (8/10), abnormal pupillary light reflexes (6/10), decreased suckling-reflex (6/9), seizures and/or nystagmus (4/10). Common
clinicopathological alterations included hyperfibrinogenaemia (8/9), hyperlactataemia (7/7), and neutropenia (5/10) or neutrophilia (5/10). Most neonates
(8/9) developed bacterial meningoencephalitis despite having a sepsis score near the cut-off value (median = 12). On CSF analysis, pleocytosis (9/9), increased
total protein concentration (5/6) and intracellular bacteria (6/9) were detected. The most frequently isolated bacterium was Escherichia coli. Once bacterial
meningoencephalitis was diagnosed, antimicrobial therapy was switched to third and fourth generation cephalosporins.
Conclusions: The diagnosis of bacterial meningoencephalitis is established based on CSF analysis and culture. Clinical recognition of bacterial
meningoencephalitis is difficult and can be easily overlooked. Moreover, severe sepsis is not necessary to develop bacterial meningoencephalitis.
Potential relevance: CSF analysis should be considered more often in sick newborn foals with signs indicative of central nervous system (CNS) involvement.
Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cytology and culture would help to confirm or rule out unnoticed bacterial meningoencephalitis, and to choose appropriate
antimicrobial therapy.
Keywords: horse; neonate; septic meningitis; sepsis; neurological disease
Introduction
Bacterial infection of the equine central nervous system (CNS) is an
uncommon condition and has been reported to affect 2.5% of horses with
neurological disease (Furr 2008). Bacterial meningoencephalitis appears
to be more frequent in neonatal foals. It is reported as a complication of
sepsis in as many as 8–10% of septic foals (Koterba et al. 1984; Brewer
and Koterba 1990) and is associated with a high mortality rates (Koterba
et al. 1984; Brewer and Koterba 1990; Sanchez et al. 2008). However,
information about bacterial meningoencephalitis in equine patients is
scarce, and some authors consider that there is a lack of comprehensive
case series of bacterial meningitis in these animals (Mitchell et al. 2007).
Reported clinical signs of bacterial meningoencephalitis, such as lethargy,
weakness, fever and seizures (Pellegrini-Masini and Livesey 2006;
Furr 2008) are nonspecific and frequently present in other common
neonatal diseases.
Early diagnosis of bacterial meningoencephalitis is essential for selection
of appropriate therapy, and for increasing the likelihood of survival.
However, clinical signs consistent with bacterial meningoencephalitis are
often observed in many critically ill foals with other diseases, such as
hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE). Thus, recognition of bacterial
meningoencephalitis based on clinical signs can be difficult. In human
medicine, it is well known that meningitis can easily go unrecognised in
septic neonates, so cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) is routinely collected in septic
infants (Heath et al. 2003).
The objective of this retrospective case series was to review the
clinical signs, causative agents, laboratory findings and outcome in foals
with confirmed bacterial meningoencephalitis admitted to a referral
equine hospital.
Materials and methods
Case selection
Data from medical records of all newborn foals (<21 days old) and foals
aged 21 days to 6 months, admitted to the Universitat Autonoma de
Barcelona from January 2004 to December 2009, with a confirmed
diagnosis of bacterial meningoencephalitis were reviewed.
Diagnosis of bacterial meningoencephalitis was confirmed by a
board-certified neurologist and was based on either bacterial growth on
CSF culture, consistent CSF analysis, or post mortem confirmation.
Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis was considered consistent with bacterial
meningoencephalitis when neutrophilic pleocytosis or intracellular
bacteria were detected. Post mortem diagnosis was reached by the
presence of either purulent CSF or histopathological evidence of bacterial
infection in the CNS. Moreover, diagnosis of sepsis in newborn foals was
reached when at least one of the following conditions occurred: positive
blood culture, increased sepsis score (>11) or post mortem findings
consistent with sepsis.
Medical record review
Data obtained from medical records included case details, clinical signs,
neurological and ophthalmological examination findings (confirmed
by a boarded neurologist and ophthalmologist, respectively), and
clinicopathological results obtained when clinical signs consistent with
bacterial meningoencephalitis were detected (total white blood cell count,
neutrophil count, packed cell volume; total plasma protein [TP], fibrinogen,
lactate, sodium, potassium and chloride concentrations; serum IgG
concentration; CSF total protein concentration, cell count and cytology;
and blood and CSF cultures). Other information included was: sepsis score
(neonatal foals) (Brewer and Koterba 1988), concurrent diseases during
hospitalisation, treatments given, outcome (survival to discharge from the
hospital, euthanasia or death due to complications from sepsis or bacterial
meningoencephalitis), and post mortem findings. Information regarding
the organisms isolated from blood and CSF samples, including bacterial
identification and antimicrobial sensitivity, was also obtained.
Results
Nine of 173 septic newborn foals (from a total of 309 sick neonates
admitted during the study period) fulfilled the inclusion criteria (Foals 1–9).
In addition, a 5-month-old foal (Foal 10) of 174 admitted foals (>21 days and
Equine Veterinary Journal ISSN 0425-1644
DOI: 10.1111/j.2042-3306.2011.00508.x
100 Equine Veterinary Journal 44, Suppl. 41 (2012) 100–104 © 2012 EVJ Ltd