Special Topic Section
Evaluation of Treatment
Eur Addict Res 2002;8:22–29
Effectiveness of a Therapeutic
Community Treatment in Spain:
A Long-Term Follow-Up Study
José-Ramo ´ n Ferna ´ ndez-Hermida Roberto Secades-Villa
José-Javier Ferna ´ ndez-Ludeña Pedro-Antonio Marina-Gonza ´ lez
Faculty of Psychology, University of Oviedo, Asturias, Spain
José-Ramo ´ n Ferna ´ ndez-Hermida
Facultad de Psicologı ´a, Universidad de Oviedo
Plaza Feijoo s/n
E–33003 Oviedo (Spain)
Tel. +34 98 5104163, Fax +34 98 5104144, E-Mail jrhermid@correo.uniovi.es
ABC
Fax + 41 61 306 12 34
E-Mail karger@karger.ch
www.karger.com
© 2002 S. Karger AG, Basel
1022–6877/02/0081–0022$18.50/0
Accessible online at:
www.karger.com/journals/ear
Key Words
Program evaluation W Therapeutic community W Drug
treatment W Drug addiction
Abstract
In this paper, the effectiveness of the treatment program
developed by Proyecto Hombre (‘Project Mankind’) in
Asturias, Spain, is evaluated. In a long-term follow-up
(range from 73 days to 8 years) with a sample of 249 sub-
jects, the results obtained by subjects completing the
treatment (194) were compared with pre-treatment re-
sults and with those of the group that dropped out (55).
The measurements used were relapses in illegal drugs,
alcohol, changes in family situation, educational level,
employment, criminal involvement and state of health.
External validation of self-report measures given in the
questionnaire was carried out. Findings support the ef-
fectiveness of the treatment in all measures and the val-
idity of self-report items. Relapse rate in ‘treatment-com-
pleted’ group was 10.3%, whilst in the non-completers
group it reached 63.6% (significant difference, p ! 0.001).
Relapses of non-completers were more severe, occurred
sooner after leaving the program (they stayed abstinent
for shorter periods) and lasted longer than those of sub-
jects completing the treatment.
Copyright © 2002 S. Karger AG, Basel
Introduction
Evaluation of Results in Therapeutic Communities
(TC)
In the specialized literature we can find an abundance
of references to studies that have assessed the treatment
carried out in TC for drug abusers. The origins of research
in this field are clearly North American [1–3]. However,
since the eighties there has been extensive and growing
European concern with the evaluation of TC treatment
outcomes [2, 3].
‘The mainstream European TC follow-up research’ [2,
p. 32] involves work from eight European countries,
among which Spain is not included, not because its contri-
bution has been overlooked, but because Spanish research
in this field is indeed scarce. Indeed, when Ferna ´ ndez-
Hermida and Secades-Villa [4] reviewed studies pub-