Influence of organic manures on carrot
(Daucus carota L.) crops grown in a
long-term field experiment in Sweden
Lars Kjellenberg
1
*, Eva Johansson
1
, Karl-Erik Gustavsson
1
, Artur Granstedt
2
and Marie E. Olsson
1
1
Department of Plant Breeding, Swedish University of Agricultural Science, P.O. Box 101, SE-230 53 Alnarp,
Sweden
2
Biodynamic Research Institute, Skilleby, SE 153 91 Järna, Sweden
*Corresponding author: lars.kjellenberg@slu.se
Accepted 8 May 2015; First published online 22 June 2015 Research Paper
Abstract
This study evaluated the effects of organic agriculture manuring systems on carrot (Daucus carota) root morphology and
sugar and polyacetylene content. Carrots were harvested three times per season 2006–2007 in a long-term field experi-
ment at Skilleby research farm, Sweden. The effects of pelleted chicken manure, fresh farmyard manure and composted
farmyard manure (COM) were compared against control plots left unmanured since the field experiment started in 1991.
The carrotswere analyzed for root size, root shape, amount of soluble sugars and amount of falcarinol-type polyacety-
lenes. Differences between manuring systems were found to be smaller than the variation between harvest years and
harvest occasions, probably due to the grass-clover ley included in the crop rotation system. On an average for the six
harvests, manuring with COM increased root length by 6% compared with fertilizing with pelleted chicken manure.
Carrots fertilized with pelleted chicken manure also had 6–7% lower total soluble sugar content than carrots
manured with 50 t ha
-1
of composted or fresh manure. The falcarinol to total falcarinol-type polyacetylenes ratio
was 15.4% in carrots manured with 50 t ha
-1
of composted or fresh manure and 14.7% in carrots fertilized with pelleted
chicken manure. Seasonal fluctuations in falcarinol-type polyacetylenes were more pronounced in carrots manured with
fresh or composted manure than in carrots fertilized with pelleted chicken manure. The results suggest that manuring
organic carrots with compost may be the most beneficial strategy, at least in systems where fertilizer is applied only
once per crop rotation, whether directly to the carrot crop or in the preceding crop.
Key word: carrot, Daucus carota, soluble sugar, root morphology, Falcarinol-type polyacetylenes, organic manuring systems
Introduction
Choice of manuring strategy is an essential factor in all
farming systems. The strategy has to consider climate,
crop rotation and both short-term and long-term objec-
tives. Within the framework of organic agriculture (OA),
many different manuring systems have evolved to meet
different demands. Previous studies on the long-term con-
sequences of OA systems have shown that differences
between manuring strategies are mainly manifested in
soil properties rather than in crop quality traits (Mäder
et al., 2002). Some differences in crop quality have been
reported (Woese et al., 1997), but these are not consistent.
Increased understanding of how different OA manuring
systems influence crop development and quality is
important when striving to grow nutritious and tasty
organic crops to an acceptable yield.
The carrot plant is biennial and root growth continues
as long as external circumstances permit, with no distinct
period of winter dormancy (Nilsson, 1987). Deciding
when to harvest a carrot crop is thus a balance between
yield, nutritive quality, storability and harvesting
conditions.
The morphological features of the carrot taproot are sug-
gested to be correlated to different quality and chemical
parameters (Rosenfeld, 2003). The shape of the carrot
taproot is mainly determined by the relationship between
its extension in length and its increase in thickness. This
gives rise to different root types, from round to conical or
more cylindrical. The initial length increase of the taproot
Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems: 31(3); 258–268 doi:10.1017/S1742170515000174
© Cambridge University Press 2015