ARTICLE IN PRESS
JID: AJSS [m5GeSdc;September 6, 2022;16:41]
Asian Journal of Social Science xxx (xxxx) xxx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Asian Journal of Social Science
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ajss
A Review of Political Violence in Southeast Asia since 1945: Case
Studies from Six Countries, Eve Monique Zucker and Ben Kiernan
(eds.), 2021, London: Routledge
Political Violence in Southeast Asia since 1945, edited by Eve Monique
Zucker and Ben Kiernan, is a valuable edited volume for scholars en-
gaged in Southeast Asia from any number of disciplines in the Humani-
ties and Social Sciences. Developed out of a 2018 conference at Yale Uni-
versity, this book, split into six thematic parts, is a thoughtfully curated
collection of pieces focused on Myanmar, Thailand, Indonesia, Philip-
pines, Cambodia, and Vietnam. By dividing the chapters thematically
rather than by these six countries covered by individual chapters, the
editors draw attention to the utility of thinking across contexts for re-
gional scholars. In doing so, the timeliness and larger implications of
this content are brought to the fore.
The introduction situates this collection within Southeast Asian Stud-
ies providing a broad overview of the history of political violence in the
region since 1945 and unpacks some of the themes cutting across the
six sections. Minorities and statelessness, rupture and uncertainty, and
the political imagination are just a few of these themes. According to
Kiernan and Zucker, this volume is not a survey of political violence
in Southeast Asia, but rather it seeks to illuminate features of violence
and shed light on events not studied. Each chapter not only provides de-
tailed accounts of these specific cases, but presents them in a way that
is globally relevant. The six parts of this volume, ranging from two to
four chapters per part, are titled: Dimensions of Mass Violence; Politics
of Fear; Minorities and the State; Technologies, Techniques and Ideolo-
gies; Justice, Ethics and History; and Shadow of the Past on the Present.
The book begins with an exploration of the concept of mass vio-
lence in two different cases in Dimensions of Mass Violence. In each of
these chapters, violence against particular groups is not shaped in isola-
tion, but in relation to other colonial and international actors. Geoffrey
Robinson’s analysis of anticommunist violence in Indonesia from 1965
to 1966 speaks to the wider significance of variegation in cases of mass
violence, not only to patterns of violence in Indonesia but to under-
standing mass violence even in the most centralized and authoritarian
of contexts. The second chapter, written by Elliott Prasse-Freeman and
Andrew Ong, also presents a powerful and nuanced take on the concept
of mass violence through the case of the Rohingya crisis in Myanmar
by unpacking the history and relationship of minority identity relative
to the state more broadly. Part Two, the Politics of Fear, consists of
three cases that contemplate the relationship between nationalism and
violence in the Philippines, Cambodia, and Myanmar. In each of these
cases, a special focus is given to the roles of order and disorder in shap-
ing the relationship between the powerful and powerless. Minorities and
the State, the third part of this volume, consists of three, largely his-
torical chapters. Topics explored include the battle of Dien Bien Phu in
Vietnam, the persecution of Vietnamese minorities in Cambodia, and the
historical background surrounding the genocide of Rohingyas in Burma.
Those who’s academic and teaching interests exist at the nexus of
practice and theory will likely find that some of the most striking con-
tributions are found in the second half of this volume. Part four, Tech-
nologies Techniques and Ideologies, presents two important case studies
that speak to growing bodies of scholarship pertaining to the history of
science and actor network theory. On the one hand, chapter ten pro-
vides chilling details of the S-21 compound in Phenom Penh, the center
of Khmer Rouge medical experiments. On the other hand, I appreci-
ated Sophie Quinn-Judge’s contextualization of US airstrikes during the
Second Indochina War within global history as well as relative to con-
temporary debates surrounding drone warfare. The following section,
Justice, Ethics and History, presents four compelling chapters that ex-
plore the legal dimensions surrounding violence. With a range of topics
covered from the regional politics of ASEAN and globally relevant topics
like legal “intent” to the intricacies of policies specific to Thailand and
Myanmar, these chapters are valuable contributions to policy makers as
well as academics. Part VI concludes this volume with three authors who
examine the relationship between violent events of the past and present
of Thailand, Vietnam and Cambodia. The content of these final chapters
connects with many of the topics covered in the first five parts, but with
a focus on contemporary political violence and issues of globalization.
While I praise the editors of this volume for shaping these chap-
ters around six different themes rather than the contexts focused on in
each chapter, I was hoping that these themes would have been further
unpacked within an introduction to each of the six parts. Further in-
corporating the categories into the six sections may have helped push
the content of each of these chapters to move beyond foundational ap-
proaches in Southeast Asian Studies that are rooted in the concept of
the nation and region itself.
As a scholar currently focused on Thailand, but looking to ex-
pand my own knowledge of the region and craft courses in Southeast
Asian Studies and Global History, this volume holds great value to me.
Tyrell Haberkorn’s chapter on the justice system as well as Puangthong
Pawakapan’s piece that unpacks the past and present of state-sponsored
right-wing groups are two contributions that I will reference for my own
work on urban politics in Thailand. However, I also appreciated the
range of content included in this book and the editor’s focus on features
of violence and events not often studied. Scholars investigating larger
themes that transcend the boundaries of nation-states and Southeast
Asia – as pertaining to the legal dynamics surrounding human rights,
the tangible and intangible violence that has resulted from colonialism,
the persecution of minorities, memory studies and the history of science
amongst many others – will find this volume a useful reference. This
range of topics and contexts covered by these authors makes this book
an important reference for instructors from political science to history
seeking to shape syllabi that are global in scope or specific to Southeast
Asia.
Trude Laura Renwick, PhD
∗
Postdoctoral Fellow
Society of Fellows in the Humanities at the University of Hong Kong,
Hong Kong, China
∗
Corresponding authors at: 609 Ashbury Street Apt 12
San Francisco, CA 94117.
E-mail addresses: trenwick@hku.hk, trude.renwick@gmail.com
Available online xxx
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajss.2022.08.005
1568-4849/© 2022 Department of Sociology, National University of Singapore. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.