ISSN 0024-9521
IJG Vol. 4 , No.1, June 2014 (1 - 11)
© 2014 Faculty of Geography UGM and
e Indonesian Geographers Association
e spatial effect of fiscal decentralisation on regional disparities:
the case from Indonesia
Adiwan F. Aritenang
Received: 05 03 2014 / Accepted: 19 03 2014 / Published online: 30 06 2014
© 2014 Faculty of Geography UGM and e Indonesian Geographers Association
Abstract is study investigates the effect of decentralization on regional economic convergence between 1994 and
2004. Using spatial analysis, this research explains the presence of spatial dependence, which it is misleading to ignore
it on the common linear regression. e paper argues that there is a strong evidence of spatial autocorrelation among
Indonesia districts and regional convergence rate is higher in the decentralization period. Furthermore, the spatial error
model suggested that, despite Jakarta’s major economic and political role, a random shock is insignificant if it introduced
to the capital city.
Abstrak Studi ini mengkaji dampak otonomi daerah terhadap konvergensi ekonomi wilayah di Indonesia antara ta-
hun 1994 dan 2004. Menggunakan teknik analisa spasial, penelitian ini menjelaskan adanya keterkaitan spasial. Studi
menjelaskan bahwa terdapat keterkaitan spasial antara kota/kabupaten di Indonesia dan terdapat konvergensi wilayah
setelah otonomi daerah. Selanjutnya, simulasi spasial menunjukkan bahwa random shock terhadap Jakarta tidak signifi-
kan terhadap ekonomi di Indonesia.
Keywords: Indonesia; Decentralization; Regional Convergence; Spatial Random Shocks
Kata kunci: Indonesia; Otonomi Daerah; Konvergensi Wilayah; Spatial Random Shocks
e neoclassical theory lies in the idea of dimin-
ishing returns that implies a long run equalization of
development. is theory seeks to explain the deter-
minants of regional convergence rate with economic
growth is regarded as a growth of real terms of per
capita income and the variables are used to measure the
convergence of the economic growth rate, between ini-
tial level of output, y, and its target, y*. Such variables
act as additional variables in the conditional conver-
gence, while absolute convergence only examines the
initial level of output and the level of the target, without
the effects of other variables. is theory has inspired
numerous studies of regional convergence with several
approaches such as cross-section, time series, and panel
data analysis.
Furthermore, there are also interests in studies the
effect of decentralization and trade liberalization on
intra-regional scale. e studies are varied in meth-
odology and geographical level of analysis with non-
spatial analysis such as Rivas [2007] that studies the
impact of devolution and Rodríguez-Pose and Bwire
[2004] that examine the impact of trade liberalization
on Mexico regions. However, following the spatial au-
tocorrelation at the regional scale theoretical studies by
Anselin [1988, 2007] and Arbia [2006], there is emerg-
A. F. Aritenang
Agency for the Assessment and Application of Technology
email: a.aritenang@gmail.com
ing empirical studies and literature on this subject. For
example, spatial econometrics analysis with in regional
convergence in the US [Rey and Montouri, 1999] and in
Turkey [Yildirim et al., 2009], and there are also studies
on the spatial effect of trade liberalization such as by
Özyurt and Daumal [2013].
While in Indonesia, there are non-spatial studies by
Akita and Lukman [1995] and Resosudarmo & Vidyat-
tama [2006]. e approach has also been implemented
in Indonesia. For instance, a case study of income and
consumption in the capital city Jakarta, using the Local
Moran analysis shows the patterns in the core city of
Jakarta and found that the sub district of Tanah Abang
has a negative association, i.e., a low value surrounded
by high values [Syabri, 2003]. e paper argues that the
sub district is an urban decay as the conversion to busi-
ness activity along with other rich sub districts in the
core city of Jakarta has not taken place. Another case
study of poverty analysis in East Java province by Pus-
pitasari, et al [2010] with a LISA cluster map illustrates
that severe poverty cluster locations has moved from
south to the north and east part of the province be-
tween 2003 to 2007. While the study by Karmaji [2010]
focuses on the agriculture location. us, there is lack
of spatial autocorrelation studies with regard on decen-
tralization in Indonesia.
is paper aims to examine the presence of spa-
tial autocorrelation in regional economic convergence
I. Introduction