Factors affecting treatment compliance in patients with bipolar I disorder during
prophylaxis: a study from Turkey
Saime Esra Col, M.D.
a
, Ali Caykoylu, M.D.
b
, Gorkem Karakas Ugurlu, M.D.
b,
⁎, Mustafa Ugurlu, M.D.
b
a
Deparment of Psychiatry, Igdır State Hospital, Igdır, Turkey
b
Department of Psychiatry, Yıldırım Beyazıt University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara Ataturk Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 20 March 2013
Revised 20 November 2013
Accepted 20 November 2013
Keywords:
Medication
Compliance
Dipolar disorder
Objectives: Treatment noncompliance is one of the most frequent causes of relapse and recurrence in patients
with bipolar I disorder. Treatment compliance among patients with bipolar disorder is affected by individual
patients’ features, the disease itself, doctor-patient relationships and patients’ socio-economic and cultural
characteristics. This study aimed to determine the factors affecting treatment compliance during the
treatment of bipolar disorder and contribute to current clinical strategies.
Methods: Data were collected from 78 volunteers with bipolar I disorder in remission; all volunteers were
being treated solely with mood stabilisers. Sociodemographic and clinical data were gathered through a semi-
structured interview designed by researchers. The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale and the Young Mania
Rating Scale were both administered to assess remission of bipolar I disorder, and a self-report scale, the
Medication Adherence Rating Scale, was administered to assess medication adherence.
Results: Treatment compliant patients reported that they had received adequate social support and had been
sufficiently informed by their physicians about the illness and treatment. Treatment compliant individuals
with higher rates of hospitalisations and the results indicate that the number of depressive episodes adversely
affects treatment compliance. There was not a statistically significant difference in treatment compliance
based on duration of illness, euthymia, time, total number of episodes, age of onset, predominant polarity,
drug doses, number of daily medications, frequency of daily medications, or type of mood stabiliser used.
Conclusions: These results indicate that there are differences between compliant and non-compliant bipolar I
disorder patients in terms of adequate social support, information provided by the physician about the illness
and treatment, number of depressive episodes and number of hospitalisations.
© 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Clinicians agree that treatment compliance is difficult to attain
and poses an obstacle to good clinical outcomes among individuals
with severe mental disorders [1]. Treatment compliance could be
defined as the patient’s acceptance of the essential health and
treatment proposals and conformity with them; this definition
includes a number of behaviours, such as accessing treatment,
accepting medication, understanding follow-up advice and remem-
bering to take medication. This definition, which cannot be limited to
describing the usage of prescribed medications, also describes the
entire set of proposals made by the clinician, including in behavioural
aspects [2–5]. The term “treatment compliance” is more compre-
hensive than “medication adherence,” a term referring only to
prescribed medications.
Psychopharmacology has significant importance in the treatment
of bipolar I disorder (BPD), both in the acute and maintenance therapy
periods. Immediately after an acute episode, many patients require
long-term prophylaxis to prevent recurrence. Despite new psycho-
pharmacological developments, treatment outcomes still depend
upon treatment compliance. Treatment noncompliance is one of the
most frequent causes of relapse and recurrence in BPD patients and is
linked to adverse outcomes, such as increased polyclinical applica-
tions, rehospitalisation, poor community adjustment [6] and suicide
[2,7–10]. These outcomes are also indicators of increased health care
utilisation and cost of health services [11]. The potential benefits of
pharmacological treatment, including recovery, relapse prevention
and reduced mortality, decrease greatly with noncompliance [2,3].
The reported noncompliance rates for long-term prophylactic
pharmacotherapy for BPD range from 20% to 66%; the mean
prevalence is noted to be 41% [2–4].
Thus far, the factors affecting treatment compliance among
patients with BPD have not been determined. Many variables related
to the patient (socioeconomic characteristics, perceptions, beliefs),
clinician (the relationship between physician and patient), treatment
(efficacy, side effects, drug dose, number of pills, number of
General Hospital Psychiatry 36 (2014) 208–213
⁎ Correspondence author. Bilkent/Ankara, Turkey. Tel.: +90 0312 291 25 25/3765;
fax: +90 03122912705.
E-mail addresses: sesrac@hotmail.com (S.E. Col), acaykoylu@hotmail.com
(A. Caykoylu), dr_gorkem@yahoo.com (G. Karakas Ugurlu), dr_ugurlu@yahoo.com
(M. Ugurlu).
0163-8343/$ – see front matter © 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2013.11.006
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
General Hospital Psychiatry
journal homepage: http://www.ghpjournal.com