Automatic ictal HFO detection for
determination of initial seizure spread
Andreas Graef, Christoph Flamm, Susanne Pirker, Christoph Baumgartner,
Manfred Deistler, Fellow, IEEE, and Gerald Matz, Senior Member, IEEE
Abstract—High-frequency oscillations (HFOs) are a reliable
indicator for the epileptic seizure onset zone (SOZ) in ECoG
recordings. We propose a novel method for the automatic
detection of ictal HFOs in the ripple band (80-250Hz) based
on CFAR matched sub-space filtering. This allows to track the
early propagation of ictal HFOs, revealing initial and follow-up
epileptic activity on the electrodes. We apply this methodology
to two seizures from one patient suffering from focal epilepsy.
The electrodes identified are in very good accordance with the
visual HFO analysis by clinicians. Furthermore the electrodes
with initial HFO activity are correlated well with the SOZ
(conventional ϑ-activity).
I. I NTRODUCTION
A. Background
Epilepsies, defined as disorders with recurrent unprovoked
seizures, affect approximately 0.7% of the general population
[1]. Seizures are characterized by abnormal synchronized neu-
ronal discharge of networks in both hemispheres (generalized
seizures) or in circumscribed networks in one hemisphere
(focal seizures). About one third of focal epilepsy patients
suffer from drug resistance, and epilepsy surgery has become a
valuable treatment option for them [2]. If a clear-cut definition
of the seizure onset zone is possible, the goal is the removal
of the epileptogenic tissue in order to abolish the seizures [3].
Up to 70% of patients with drug resistant focal epilepsy be-
come seizure free following surgery [4]. Presurgical evaluation
comprises prolonged video-EEG recording, high resolution
brain imaging as well as neuropsychological tests. If scalp
EEG cannot provide sufficient information on the seizure onset
zone (SOZ), invasive recording using subdural strip electrodes
(electrocorticography, ECoG), which are placed directly on
the cortex, is performed in order to determine the epileptic
focus [5].
Clinical experts perform the analysis of initial seizure
propagation including the determination of the SOZ by visual
inspection of the raw ECoG recordings. This current gold
standard (cf. [6] and [7] for two recent studies) is based
Manuscript received April 12th, 2013
A. Graef (e-mail: andreas.graef@tuwien.ac.at), C. Flamm and M. Deistler are
with Vienna University of Technology, Institute for Mathematical Methods in
Economics; Vienna, Austria.
G. Matz is with Vienna University of Technology, Institute of Telecommuni-
cations; Vienna, Austria
S. Pirker and C. Baumgartner are with Hospital Hietzing with Neurological
Center Rosenhügel; Vienna, Austria.
on the onset of ictal rhythmic activity (mostly in the ϑ-
or δ-frequency band, [8]). In the last years, a new class of
biomarkers has received growing attention [9]: high-frequency
oscillations (HFOs), which are low-amplitude EEG correlates
commonly observed in two sub-bands, as ripples (80-250Hz)
and fast ripples (250-500Hz). They occur interictally as well
as ictally [10], and interictal HFOs are excellent markers of
the SOZ (higher sensitivity and specificity than spikes, cf. e.g.
[11], [12]). In the following we will be interested in ictal HFOs
only. They correlate well with the SOZ as well (cf. e.g. [13])
and typically occur several seconds before conventional EEG
onset, with a range between 8s [14] and 20s [15].
B. Contributions and state of the art
The visual inspection of ECoG data for HFO analysis is a
time-demanding, highly subjective task which depends heavily
on the individual experience of the investigator. Therefore we
suggest a complementary computational approach based on
classical signal detection methodology, compare subsection
II-A.
Several automated HFO detection algorithms have already
been proposed in literature. First attempts included rather
simple approaches based on band-pass filtering and subsequent
use of detection statistics like RMS [16], Teager Energy [17],
Line Length ([18] and [19]) or the Hilbert transform [20].
In order to decrease false-positives, increasingly compli-
cated multi-step approaches based on the above ideas have
come up in the last years, e.g. [21], [22] and [23], and very
recently [24].
While these studies focus on the automatic detection of
HFOs in interictal EEG (or in databases including ictal
and interictal phases), we limit ourselves to the analysis of
ictal ECoG recordings. In contrast to the aforementioned
approaches, we are not interested in the generation of statistics
of HFO rates, but want to track the spread of initial HFOs.
For this analysis, seizure onset time is provided by clinicians.
Therefore, our contributions to the area of HFO analysis are
twofold:
1) We propose a novel algorithm for automatic detection
of HFOs.
2) We track the propagation of initial ictal HFOs. Channels
showing first HFOs indicate the SOZ (of conventional
ictal activity).
35th Annual International Conference of the IEEE EMBS
Osaka, Japan, 3 - 7 July, 2013
978-1-4577-0216-7/13/$26.00 ©2013 IEEE 2096