Exploring the Constructions of Masculine Identities
among St. Lucian Men
Tracy Davis Alvin Thomas
Western Illinois University Morehouse College
Christopher Sewalish
Western Illinois University
Twenty St. Lucian men were interviewed using a constructivist
approach aimed at better understanding participants’ gender-
related development. Emerging themes included a masculine iden-
tity intertwined with responsibility and independence, aversion to
gay men, gender-related role tension, and the powerful influence
of parents and teachers on gender role expectations. Implications
from this study support the need to promote healthy development
by understanding the powerful gender and cultural dimensions
relating to identity formation.
Keywords: men’s development, men’s identity, masculine iden-
tity, St. Lucian, Caribbean masculinities
Back then as a teenager you’d wear anything to suit other people
… to have people favor you, but wearing a suit … people watch
you on a whole different level. (Tyler)
This reflection, shared by a participant in the present study, captures an impor-
tant essence of identity development. Specifically, the formation of identity is not
simply an internal organic process but one that reflects the dominant influences of
acculturation and socialization (Chickering & Reisser, 1993; D’Augelli, 1994; Jones
& McEwen, 2000). Societal messages regarding gender and sex roles powerfully
influence perceptions of self as well as shape what is considered appropriate behav-
292
Tracy Davis, College Student Personnel Program Coordinator, Western Illinois University; Alvin
Thomas, Department of Psychology, Morehouse College; Christopher Sewalish, Department of College
Student Personnel, Western Illinois University.
Correspondence for this article should be addressed to Tracy Davis, 1 University Circle, Horrabin
Hall 80, Macomb, IL 61455-1390. Electronic mail: tl-davis1@wiu.edu
The Journal of Men’s Studies, Vol. 14, No. 3, Fall 2006, 292-310.
© 2006 by the Men’s Studies Press, LLC. All rights reserved.
1060-8265.1403.292