A Systematic Simulation and Proposed Optimization of the Pressure
Swing Adsorption Process for N
2
/CH
4
Separation under External
Disturbances
Weina Sun,
†
Yuanhui Shen,
†
Donghui Zhang,*
,†
Huawei Yang,
†
and Hui Ma
‡
†
Collaborative Innovation Center of Chemical Science and Engineering, School of Chemical Engineering and Technology, Tianjin
University, Tianjin 300072, China
‡
School of Architecture, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China
ABSTRACT: This work presents a detailed study of the systematic simulation, optimization, and control of a pressure swing
adsorption (PSA) process that used activated carbon as adsorbent to recover CH
4
from a gas mixture (70% N
2
/30% CH
4
). The
state-of-the-art reduced space successive quadratic-programming (r-SQP) optimization algorithm is employed to find the optimal
values of the decision variables with additional constraints. The best closed loop recovery obtained for the PSA system under
consideration is around 98% with purity of 80%. The control strategy is based on the regulatory proportional-integral-
derivative (PID) controller because of its practicability and stability. Additional constraints that guaranteed the flexibility and
adaptability of the PID controller were imposed on the optimization-based PSA system. The ability of the control system to
reject various disturbances was evaluated and compared with the open loop conditions. Results demonstrated that the well-
designed control system showed a wonderful performance in the presence of multiple disturbances.
1. INTRODUCTION
In coal bed methane (CBM), N
2
and CH
4
are the main
components and the concentration of methane usually lies
between 20% and 35%, which means the CBM is unable to be
utilized directly. In China, most CBM is discharged into the
atmosphere, which is a waste of a resource and increases the
greenhouse effect.
1
The greenhouse warming potential of CH
4
is 25 times higher than that of the well-known greenhouse gas
carbon dioxide.
2
From the standpoint of environmental
protection, upgrading the low-concentration coal bed methane
is extremely advantageous with the more stringent restriction
on the emission amount of greenhouse gases such as carbon
dioxide and methane. Meanwhile, methane has a lower cost
than traditional fossil fuels such as gasoline or diesel, which can
generate significant economic benefit
3,4
in the face of the severe
global energy situation. To remove the existing nitrogen, many
unit operations of chemical engineering such as cryogenic
distillation,
5
membrane-based separation,
6
and pressure swing
adsorption (PSA)
1,7-9
have been proven to be feasible. Among
all the feasible unit operations, PSA proved itself to be the most
desirable because of its low operating cost compared with
cryogenic distillation and efficient automatic operation in
contrast with membrane-based separation.
The inventions of PSA occurred before the underlying
theories behind it were fully understood. Since its practical
application in the late 1950s, PSA technology has evidenced
substantial growth in terms of scale, versatility, and complex-
ity.
10
The PSA process consists of multiple interactive beds
filled with adsorbents and operates in a cyclic manner, which is
called periodic operation. To simulate and optimize the PSA
system, rigorous mathematical models consisting of coupled
partial differential and algebraic equations (PDAEs) distributed
over time and space that describe material, energy, and the
momentum balances together with transport phenomena and
equilibrium equations have to be formulated to describe the
highly nonlinear nature and dynamic behavior of the real PSA
plants.
11,12
In the last three decades, many mathematical
models of adsorption beds with different complexities have
been established and simulated. Owing to the tedious and time-
consuming solution procedure of the thousands of PDAEs of
the whole PSA system, those not only accurate but also
simplified models are desirable to decrease the essential
computational time and accelerate optimization studies.
13
In
addition to its highly nonlinear and dynamic nature, the PSA
system poses extra challenges because of its highly interactive
characteristics among process variables, especially design
parameters such as step times, pressure, temperature, gas
velocity, and bed dimensions. Consequently, it is difficult to
find the optimum conditions through experiments of trial and
error, which is a waste of time and an irrational utilization of
resources.
A great deal of research concerning simulation and
optimization of simplified model-based PSA processes has
been reported in the literature. Nilchan proposed a complete
discretization approach.
14
In this approach, the space and the
temporal domain are discretized simultaneously, which reduces
the PDAEs-based model equations to a large set of nonlinear
algebraic equations. The resulting optimization formulation is a
rather small nonlinear programming (NLP) problem which is
easy to solve using a standard NLP solver. Jiang et al. apply the
direct determination approach proposed by Smith and
Westerberg
16
and Croft and LeVan
17
and simultaneous tailored
approach, a reduced space successive quadratic-programming
Received: March 24, 2015
Revised: July 6, 2015
Accepted: July 9, 2015
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.iecr.5b01862
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX