116 CLUES • Volume 40, Number 2
CLUES
•
A Journal of Detection / Volume 40, Number 2 / Fall 2022 / pp 116–118 /
ISSN 0742-4248 / eISBN 978-1-4766-4774-6 / © 2022 McFarland & Company, Inc
Somebody That I Used to Know:
Reading Gendered Silences
in the Sherlock Holmes Canon
Tom Ue
Abstract. Tis article attends to some of the silenced women in Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock
Holmes stories and recommends ways to encourage students both to think about and to respond
to them ethically and imaginatively
Black Lives Matter has fundamentally changed my teaching practice On the one
hand, this movement has prompted me to diversify my reading lists and to think about
how and why I teach familiar texts On the other, it has encouraged me to re-evaluate my
roles as a scholar, a teacher, and an administrator; to involve students in this important
conversation; and to illustrate in the classroom how we can perform activism by means of
our critical and creative activities At Dalhousie University, in Halifax, I work with many
students, some of whom know (without having read) Sherlock Holmes I have taught
Arthur Conan Doyle’s fiction in four undergraduate courses: Reading Popular Culture
(2018–19), Foundations of Science Fiction (2018), Modernisms and Masculinities (2019),
and Writing for University (2022) In winter 2022, I made Holmes the theme of Writing
for University, a first-year offering that introduces students to academic writing Over
14 weeks, we examined many stories and adaptations I stress the relevance of genre fic-
tion in the present day, and I encourage students to listen to the voices and the silences
of those who are marginalized as a means of responding ethically and imaginatively to
these works
The Holmes canon is rife, for example, with female characters who appear only to dis-
appear Mary Morstan is first introduced to us in The Sign of Four (1890) She is, according
Tom Ue is assistant professor in literature and science at Dalhousie University. He is the author of Gissing,
Shakespeare, and the Life of Writing (Edinburgh UP, forthcoming) and George Gissing (Liverpool UP,
forthcoming), as well as the editor of George Gissing: The Private Papers of Henry Ryecroft (Edinburgh
UP, forthcoming).