Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Applied Acoustics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/apacoust
Centrifugal fan with inclined blades for vacuum cleaner motor
Jurij Prezelj, Tadej Novaković
⁎
University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Aškerčeva 6, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Centrifugal fan
Impeller
Inclined blades
Aeroacoustics
Psychoacoustics
Noise
ABSTRACT
Centrifugal fans have several technical applications. Their aerodynamic performance is well-optimized nowa-
days, but the same does not apply to their acoustic performance. Noise control studies of centrifugal fans are
often focused on designed operating conditions or operating conditions close to the onset of instability. This
paper seeks to find an alternative geometry of the centrifugal fan impeller which would improve noise control of
centrifugal fans in a wide range of operating conditions. In this paper, the term noise control refers to noise level
reduction and additionally to manipulating the psychoacoustic properties of noise.
The experimental work and numerical calculations focus on the centrifugal fan in vacuum cleaners. The
experimental work, based on numerical simulations, is described to investigate the influence of the triangular
cross section on the flow channel, formed by two inclined blades in opposite directions, on aerodynamic
properties and the psychoacoustic performance of the impeller. The study demonstrates that impellers with a
triangular flow channel achieve an aerodynamic performance which is comparable to that of standard impellers.
The results also show that impellers with inclined blades deliver superior results in psychoacoustic metrics
compared to impellers with upright blades.
1. Introduction
The noise generated by vacuum cleaners is the most recognizable
noise source among all household appliances with a suction unit as the
dominant source of noise. The suction unit is an original equipment
manufacturer product, assembled from an electric motor, an impeller
and a protective cover, forming a vaneless diffuser and airflow chan-
nels. Quieter and less annoying vacuum cleaners can be designed only
by installing quieter and less annoying suction units; performing noise
control measures on the suction unit itself is therefore inevitable. The
dominant source of noise in the suction unit is its impeller and this
study therefore focuses on noise control of the impeller. In this paper,
the term noise control refers to noise level reduction and additionally to
manipulating the psychoacoustic properties of noise.
The suction unit generates noise due to its vibrating surfaces (vi-
bration-induced noise) and due to pressure pulsations in the airflow
(aerodynamically generated noise). The level of vibration-induced
noise and the level of flow-induced noise are comparable to the same
type of noise levels in large fans. In the case of small and medium-sized
fans, which are the main focus of this paper, aerodynamically generated
noise is dominant [1]. The level of vibration-induced noise in a suction
unit is typically at least 10 dB lower than the level of aerodynamically
generated noise, making the latter the dominant source of noise in any
suction unit [2]. Aerodynamically generated noise has both tonal and
broadband characteristics. Discrete or narrowband tonal noise is cor-
related with rotation and the blade passing frequency (BPF), along with
its higher harmonics. Turbulent noise is characterized by a broadband
frequency spectrum [3].
Tonal noise is usually the dominant element of the total noise level
and the main disturbing aspect of noise. Tones are produced as a result
of regular cyclic motion of the fan’s blades with respect to a stationary
observer, and by interacting with adjacent structures [4,5]. Flow in-
teractions between the impeller and the volute casing cause periodic
pressure fluctuations on the impeller’s solid walls and casing. These
periodic pressure fluctuations are the sources of aerodynamic tonal
noise radiation, mathematically described by dipole sources, as well as
periodic structural vibrations resulting in tonal noise [6].
Reduction of the tonal noise level with BPF is essential for overall
noise control and for reducing the irritating character of suction unit
noise. Scientists have long been concerned with this problem and sev-
eral diverse solutions have already been proposed. Neise summarized
the methods for noise reduction of the centrifugal fan and proposed the
following: (1) increasing cut-off clearance, (2) increasing the radius of
the cut-off edge’s curvature, (3) increasing the angle of inclination
between the impeller’s blades and cut-off edge, (4) staggering the
blades of double inlet or double row impellers, (5) mounting wire
meshes along the inner and outer circumference of the radial blade row,
(6) irregular blade spacing, (7) mismatch between the acoustic
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apacoust.2018.05.010
Received 28 November 2017; Received in revised form 29 March 2018; Accepted 6 May 2018
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: tadej.novakovic@fs.uni-lj.si (T. Novaković).
Applied Acoustics 140 (2018) 13–23
0003-682X/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T