608
CCC 62:4 / JUNE 2011
CCC 62:4 / JUNE 2011
Kara Poe Alexander
Successes, Victims, and Prodigies: “Master”
and “Little” Cultural Narratives in the Literacy
Narrative Genre
This article examines the “master” and “little” cultural narratives students perform in
literacy narratives. Results show that students incorporate the literacy-equals-success
master narrative most often, yet they also include in little narratives figures such as the
hero, victim, and child prodigy. I consider how these findings can improve instruction
on this topic and conclude with pedagogical recommendations.
Third grade was haunted by state-mandated writing portfo-
lios. Pressures on the teachers and changes in the curriculum
because of KERA
1
became evident to me, even in the third grade.
The hamburger method, brainstorming, and pre-writing work-
sheets took away any enjoyment I had with writing. I neglected
the pencil and paper outside of the classroom and cringed at
the mention of writing. Writing was no longer a leisurely activity
for me but a required assignment. Being forced to write took
away whatever joy was once there for me and replaced it with
contempt. I wanted to give up writing all together.
Rebekah, first-year composition student
Copyright © 2011 by the National Council of Teachers of English. All rights reserved.