ADAPTING DATA FROM AERATED BIOLOGICAL FILTERS TO DESIGN
UNAERATED RECIRCULATING SAND FILTERS FOR CARBON AND NITROGEN
REMOVAL FOR WASTEWATER TREATMENT IN DEVELOPING ECONOMIES
Thor Young and John Brinkley – Stearns & Wheler, LLC *
Dipankar Sen – Santa Clara Valley Water Authority
Marty Johnson and Chip Yaniga – Anne Arundel County, Maryland
Redouane Choukr-Allah, Institut Agronomique et Vétérinaire Hassan II
Ramzi Sabella – United States Agency for International Development
Mohammed Mansour – Water Authority of Jordan
Joseph Karam – ECODIT, Inc.
* Stearns & Wheler, LLC
16701 Melford Boulevard, Suite 330
Bowie, MD 20715
ABSTRACT
In developing economies such as Morocco, nearly 70% of all of the wastewater treatment plants
are not functioning due to lack of spare parts and poor cost recovery (USEPA, September 2004).
Intermittent and recirculating sand filters offer a treatment technology with minimal electro-
mechanical components and low operating costs, which is advantageous to sustainable
wastewater treatment for developing economies. When properly designed with the correct
nitrification kinetics and operated to prevent accumulation of excess biofilm biomass within the
filters, such systems can achieve a high degree of nitrification. The use of recirculating sand
filters in conjunction with low-maintenance, low-cost technologies provide an affordable
treatment system for nitrogen removal with beneficial opportunities.
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) removal and nitrification rates were determined from
converting unaerated recirculating sand filter (U-RSF) to an aerated recirculating sand filter (A-
RSF) for full-scale installations in the U.S. and abroad. These rates were adapted to design U-
RSFs for carbon removal and nitrification at additional wastewater treatment facilities in
developing economies. The COD removal and nitrification rates achieved in an U-RSF filter
which was overloaded were successfully increased with aeration to reduce effluent ammonium-N
levels from a range of 10 to 20 mg/L to less than 1 mg/L. The differences in COD removal and
nitrification kinetics observed during unaerated and aerated conditions were studied and applied
to the design of U-RSFs for nitrogen removal in Morocco and Jordan.
Upflow biological aerated filters (BAFs) with periodic backwashing, such as Infilco
Degremont’s Biofor
®
and Kruger’s Biostyr
®
, can achieve simultaneous carbon removal and
nitrification, with rates of 1 kg/m
3
/d at liquid temperatures of 12 to 15
o
C, when the influent
soluble biodegradable COD is less than 20 mg/L. These conditions typically exist downstream of
a first-stage COD removal system, such as an activated sludge or fixed-film biological treatment
system. The nitrification rate achieved in an A-RSF operating without backwash was lower,
averaging 0.5 kg/m
3
/d at temperatures of 10 to 22 C. For U-RSFs installed without aeration
systems in developing economies, the only means of aerating the biofilm is by raking the filter
1052
Nutrient Removal 2007
Copyright ©2007 Water Environment Federation. All Rights Reserved