Rate and Time Course of Improvement in
Endocrine Function After More Than 1000
Pituitary Operations
P
ituitary lesions occur quite commonly in
the general population, with a prevalence
ranging from 2.7% up to as high as 26.7%
based on autopsy and magnetic resonance (MR)
imaging studies.
1-3
Patients with lesions large
enough to cause symptoms present with a variety
of concerns, one of which is hypopituitarism, but
endocrine deficits may also be found on the initial
workup of patients presenting with other indica-
tors such as headache or visual deficits. The
incidence of hypopituitarism in any 1 axis from
sellar lesions has been reported to be 58%,
4
and
has been reported to be somewhat higher at 69%
to 85% with adenomas, in particular.
5,6
The
limited number of studies that have looked at
individual axes have suggested that the incidence
of deficits vary by axis.
7,8
This hypopituitarism is believed to result from
compression and destruction of the pituitary
gland by the expanding lesion, while focal
necrosis resulting from inhibition of the portal
vessels and pituitary stalk may also play a role.
9
The true incidence of endocrine recovery fol-
lowing the resection of pituitary lesions is
unclear, because many patients receive hormonal
replacement therapy indefinitely, limiting the
ability to correctly assess this variable.
Studies of improved pituitary function after
transsphenoidal surgery for nonfunctional adeno-
mas have reported considerably variable rates,
ranging from 20% of patients
6,10
up to 50% of
patients,
11,12
but those studies have failed to look
at the improvement rates for individual endocrine
axes. Other studies have suggested that improve-
ment varies by pathology, being more common
after surgery for acromegaly than surgery for
nonfunctional adenomas
13
and being uncommon
after surgery for Rathke cleft cysts.
14
Studies that
have looked at endocrine recovery by specific axis
have suggested that recovery varies by axis from
13% to 57% but have been done in smaller
cohorts of 35 to 126 patients.
5,7-9
Furthermore,
studies focusing on endocrine function recovery
after surgery for different tumor types have also
involved cohorts of limited size.
15
To address the improvement in endocrine deficits
by individual axes after transsphenoidal surgery for
the types of pathologies encountered in typical
practice in a large cohort, we analyzed preoperative
and postoperative endocrine function before and
after more than 1000 consecutive pituitary surgeries
conducted since we established a center of pituitary
expertise 5 years ago.
METHODS
Study Design, Setting, and Participants
We conducted a retrospective review of our 1015
consecutive endonasal pituitary operations on the first
916 patients treated in the 5 years since the California
Center for Pituitary Disorders, a dedicated multidis-
ciplinary center of pituitary expertise, was established.
The 1015 operations consisted of 875 first surgeries
performed at our center, 99 reoperations performed at
our center on patients whose first surgery was also at
our center, and 41 reoperations performed at our
center on patients whose first surgery was performed
elsewhere. Only endonasal procedures were included,
and craniotomies were excluded. Our institutional
Committee on Human Research reviewed and
approved this study.
Preoperative Variables Recorded
The parameters collected after review of the
medical record included age, sex, lesion size, number
of prior pituitary surgeries, lesion type (endocrine-
inactive adenoma, endocrine-active adenoma,
Rathke cleft cyst, apoplexy, craniopharyngioma, or
other), endonasal surgical approach (966 micro-
scopic operations vs 49 endoscopic), lesion location
(sellar, suprasellar, or sellar with suprasellar exten-
sion), and the presence of preoperative hypopituita-
rism. Preoperative hypopituitarism was defined
based on normal reference ranges from the Univer-
sity of California at San Francisco Department of
Laboratory Medicine by axis as (1) low free T4 (,10
pmol/L) with normal or low thyroid-stimulating
hormone (TSH) (,4.12 mIU/L); (2) amenorrhea
with low follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) (,20
IU/L); (3) testosterone less than 141 ng/dL; (4)
cortisol less than 4 mg/dL; and (5) insulin-like
growth factor 1 (IGF-1) below 87 mg/L for male
and 64 mg/L for female patients.
Arman Jahangiri, BS*‡
Jeffrey Wagner, BS*‡
Sung Won Han‡
Mai T. Tran, BS‡
Liane M. Miller, BS‡
MaxwelL W. Tom, BS‡
Lauren R. Ostling, MD§
Sandeep Kunwar, MD‡
Lewis Blevins, MD‡
Manish K. Aghi, MD, PhD‡
‡Department of Neurosurgery and The
California Center for Pituitary Disorders,
University of California at San Francisco,
San Francisco, California; §Department of
Neurosurgery, University of Cincinnati,
Cincinnati, Ohio
*These authors have contributed equally
to this work.
Correspondence:
Manish K. Aghi, MD, PhD,
Associate Professor of Neurological
Surgery Co-Director,
The California Center for Pituitary
Disorders (CCPD) and Center for Minimally
Invasive Skull Base Surgery (MISB),
University of California at San Francisco
(UCSF), 505 Parnassus Ave,
Room M779, San Francisco,
CA 94143-0112.
E-mail: AghiM@neurosurg.ucsf.edu
Copyright © 2014 by the
Congress of Neurological Surgeons.
INTEGRA FOUNDATION AWARD
INTEGRA FOUNDATION AWARD
CLINICAL NEUROSURGERY VOLUME 61 | NUMBER 1 | AUGUST 2014 | 163
Copyright © Congress of Neurological Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited