Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Structures
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/structures
Effect of soil-pile raft-structure interaction on elastic and inelastic seismic
behaviour
Rajib Saha
a
, Sekhar Chandra Dutta
b,
⁎
, Sumanta Haldar
c
, Sumit Kumar
b
a
Department of Civil Engineering, National Institute of Technology Agartala (NIT Agartala), Agartala, 799046 Tripura, India
b
Department of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology(ISM) Dhanbad (IIT(ISM) Dhanbad), Dhanbad, 826004 Jharkahand, India
c
Department of Civil Engineering, School of Infrastructure, Indian Institute of Technology Bhubaneswar (IIT Bhubaneswar), Bhubaneswar, 751013 Odisha, India
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Seismic behaviour
Soil-structure-interaction
Multi-degrees freedom
Inelastic displacement
Degrading behaviour
Elasto-plastic behaviour
ABSTRACT
Review of literature in the field of soil-pile raft-structure interaction indicates that considerable research effort
was rendered towards to achieve accuracy in dynamic soil structure interaction (DSSI) model. Interestingly,
limited results are available for design response of whole structural system. It is relevant to mention that pile
damage (bending) has become a cause of distress in structures. In this context, an effort is devoted in the present
paper to see whether DSSI have an adverse effect on elastic as well as inelastic behaviour in superstructure and
foundation. This becomes possible through adopting a simplified substructure based DSSI modelling approach.
Main focus of the present work is nonlinear seismic response of the whole structure with emphasis on con-
sideration of material nonlinearity in both pile and soil which may contribute in salient design inputs towards
performance based design of the whole structural system. Study reveals that consideration of DSSI condition
results in inelastic deformation of superstructure and it exhibits marginal increase at higher stories. On the other
hand significant increase in deformation at ground storey columns is observed if pile is restricted to deform
within elastic range. In fact, initiation of smaller inelastic deformation of pile will lead to further increment in
storey displacement, while such storey deformation will gradually decrease with higher inelastic range of de-
formation in piles and may be beneficial for superstructure system. Hence, designing of pile members with high
ductility may reduce the seismic risk of failure of superstructure system. This physical insight may be an im-
portant consideration for performance based seismic design of structures.
1. Introduction
Pile foundation is considered to be a well engineered solution for
supporting high-rise or heavy structures founded in a very soft to
medium soil. Considerable attention of researchers has been received
after failure of different pile supported structures during several
earthquakes (e.g., Mexico City earthquake 1985, Loma Prieta earth-
quake 1989, Kobe earthquake 1995, Bhuj earthquake 2001) to in-
culcate further research in this direction [1–6]. Failures of pile foun-
dation were observed during past earthquakes due to soil liquefaction,
lateral spreading in saturated cohesionless deposit, amplification of
ground motion and kinematic as well as inertial interaction in soft
ground. Conventionally, superstructure is designed considering support
to be fixed at base in case of pile supported structures. Dynamic soil-
structure interaction (DSSI) is often ignored in most of the analyses
pertaining to its complexity in modeling the system. In fact, a common
perception is that the SSI reduces the design forces at least for medium
to long period structures and thus the structure becomes over-safe if it is
designed on the basis of fixed base assumption. However, Mylonakis
et al. [7] reported that such notion leads to an unsafe design and may
even cause failure of the whole structure as is evident from the past
earthquakes (e.g., 1995 Kobe earthquake and 1985 Mexico City
earthquake). Tabatabaiefar and Clifton [8] in there comprehensive
literature survey highlighted the detrimental influence of soil structure
interaction (SSI) for unbraced building structures on soft soil. A com-
parative study by Far [9] on dynamic response of structure with flexible
and fixed base system showed that base shear of the flexible base
system is less than the fixed base system, whereas the inter-storey drift
of the structure substantially increases with the consideration of SSI.
Far [10] compared the different well known modeling techniques and
computational methods for dynamic SSI analysis and finally concluded
about most reliable modeling technique have been identified and
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.istruc.2020.04.022
Received 12 December 2019; Received in revised form 24 March 2020; Accepted 15 April 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: rajib.iitbbsr@gmail.com (R. Saha), sekhar@iitism.ac.in, scdind2000@gmail.com (S.C. Dutta), sumanta@iitbbs.ac.in (S. Haldar),
smtkumar36@gmail.com (S. Kumar).
Structures 26 (2020) 378–395
2352-0124/ © 2020 Institution of Structural Engineers. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T