The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-020-05222-z
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
On the effect of the measurement error on Shewhart t and EWMA t
control charts
Huu Du Nguyen
1
· Kim Phuc Tran
2
· Giovanni Celano
3
· Petros E. Maravelakis
4
· Philippe Castagliola
5
Received: 19 September 2019 / Accepted: 18 March 2020
© Springer-Verlag London Ltd., part of Springer Nature 2020
Abstract
In the industrial practice, control charts are frequently implemented assuming that the quality characteristic of interest can be
accurately measured without errors. In general, this assumption is not realistic: measurement error always exists in quality
control applications and may considerably affect the performance of control charts in detecting the occurrence of an out-of-
control condition. In this paper, the effect of measurement error on the statistical performance of Shewhart t and EWMA
t control charts is investigated. Several tables are provided to show how the statistical performance of these control charts
changes with different sources of the measurement error. The obtained results show that the measurement errors have a
significant influence on the performance of both the Shewhart t and EWMA t control charts. Two examples in the analytical
chemistry and food industry are presented to illustrate the use of the proposed charts.
Keywords Measurement errors · t Char · EWMA chart · Markov chain · Statistical process control
1 Introduction
Control charts are widespread statistical process control
(SPC) means to perform online process monitoring. The
Kim Phuc Tran
kim-phuc.tran@ensait.fr
Huu Du Nguyen
dunh@donga.edu.vn
Giovanni Celano
giovanni.celano@unict.it
Petros E. Maravelakis
maravel@unipi.gr
Philippe Castagliola
philippe.castagliola@univ-nantes.fr
1
Institute of Artificial Intelligence and Data Science, Dong A
University, Danang, Vietnam
2
Ecole Nationale Sup´ erieure des Arts et Industries Textiles,
GEMTEX Laboratory, 59056, Roubaix, France
3
Department of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Universit` a
di Catania, Catania, Italy
4
Department of Business Administration, University
of Piraeus, Piraeus, Greece
5
LS2N UMR CNRS 6004, Universit´ e de Nantes, Nantes, France
implementation of a control chart requires the collection of
a sample of n observations for a quality parameter to be
monitored, the derivation of a proper sample statistic, and
plotting this statistic vs. a control interval to state if the
process is running in the in-control or the out-of-control
state [1]. In SPC literature, several control charts have been
proposed to monitor the mean and/or the dispersion of a
single quality characteristic (see [2]).
In 2009, Zhang et al. [3] showed that the
¯
X chart is
not robust against errors in estimating the process standard
deviation or in situations where the standard deviation is
changing. Therefore, they developed the Shewhart t and
EWMA t control charts using the T
i
statistic which is more
robust than the classical mean
¯
X
i
statistic against changes
in the process standard deviation. Then, the properties
and design of t -type control charts have been thoroughly
investigated by many authors. For further details, readers
can do reference to, for instance, [4–8] and [9]. In these
studies, the effect of measurement error on the Shewhart
t and EWMA t control charts has not been investigated
yet. But, in practice, the measurement process often adds
errors which may adversely affect the performance of the
implemented control charts.
Generally, a measurement error exists when a measure
X
∗
of the true but unobservable value X of the quality
characteristic is collected during a sampling inspection.
Measurement errors are known to affect the statistical