Effects of mellowing sulfate-bearing clay soil stabilized with wastepaper sludge ash
for road construction
Mohamad Nidzam Rahmat ⁎, John M. Kinuthia
Civil Engineering Research Unit (CERU), Department of Engineering, Faculty of Advanced Technology, University of Glamorgan, Pontypridd, CF37 1DL, UK
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 25 March 2010
Received in revised form 15 October 2010
Accepted 19 October 2010
Available online 27 October 2010
Keywords:
Oxford Clay
Mellowing
Wastepaper
Stabilization
Sulfate
Engineering properties
The main objective of this research was to investigate the effect of mellowing on the swelling properties of
stabilized Lower Oxford Clay (LOC), a sulfate-bearing clay soil that has caused concern in the past due to
expansion upon stabilization. Two stabilizers were used, quicklime and a more sustainable stabilizer —
wastepaper sludge ash (WSA), an industrial by-product used on its own and in combination with either
quicklime (CaO) or ground granulated blastfurnace slag (GGBS). Quicklime was used on its own as a control.
Compacted cylinders of LOC stabilized with the various stabilizers were made either mellowed (compacted
3 days after mixing with stabilizer) or unmellowed (compacted immediately after mixing with stabilizer).
The linear expansion of the stabilized cylinders during moist curing and subsequent soaking was monitored
for a total of 100 days. The results obtained showed that the linear expansion of unmellowed stabilized LOC
was significantly reduced, and thus in terms of swelling potential, mellowing was not beneficial in the LOC
system investigated. The results observed also suggest that there are technological, economic as well as
environmental advantages of utilizing WSA and similar industrial by-products, in the stabilization of sulfate-
bearing and other clay soils, as an alternative to the traditional stabilizers of lime and/or Portland Cement.
© 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Good quality sub-grade soils are necessary for durable roads. Such
soils are not always available, and the Highway Engineer is likely to
face weak or unsuitable sub-grade soils as a result of either low load-
bearing capacity, and/or high swelling properties. Volume changes of
some clayey soils, resulting from changes in their water content, may
cause unpredictable movement of structures that are founded on such
soils, resulting in heaving, shear failure, excessive settlement, cracking
and breaking up. This is a particular problem with road pavements
which are founded on such soils (Mowafy et al., 1990). Many
problems associated with expansive soils have been reported all
over the world by soil engineers since about 1940 (Chen, 1975). Since
then, much research has been published on the road construction
problems of expansive clays and low load-bearing capacity soils in
general. For sulfate-bearing soils in particular, sulfate attack is mostly
accompanied by strength loss and large volume changes, resulting in
substantial heave in stabilized earthworks (Veith, 2000). Many
researchers have reported examples of detrimental effects of sulfates,
either naturally present in the ground or artificially added when soils
are modified or stabilized with lime and/or cement. Examples include
Mitchell (1986) and Hunter (1988) in the USA, and Snedker and
Temporal (1990) and Parker (2004) in the UK. Snedker and Temporal
(1990) outlined the disastrous results in lime stabilization during the
construction of the M40 motorway near Banbury, U.K. where the
presence of 0.4% sulfates resulted in 60% heave of the stabilized
capping layer. Parker (2004) reported that sulfate attack of the lime-
stabilized capping layer of the new carriageways on the 7.5 km A10
Wadesmill bypass U.K. resulted in heave that left up to 25% of the
carriageways buckled, cracked and ridged.
The expansion in lime-stabilized clay in the presence of sulfates is
believed to be partly caused by the growth of ettringite crystals
formed on the clay particle surfaces (Mitchell, 1986). Mehta (1983)
found that ettringite formed in the presence of lime was needle-like,
with a large surface area and unsatisfied negative charge. From the
observation of swelling in a Portland Cement (PC) system, he
concluded that the colloidal ettringite would imbibe large numbers
of water molecules and generate swelling pressure leading to overall
expansion of the system. Similarly, Wild et al. (1993), researching on
industrial kaolinite clay stabilized with various lime and gypsum
contents, agreed with Mehta (1983) that osmotic swelling would take
place within the colloidal layer in regions of high sulfate concentra-
tion in close proximity to the developing ettringite rods at the clay
particle surfaces. When in a saturated condition, ettringite grows and
develops from this colloidal product. During this growth, colloidal
ettringite possesses the capability of imbibing large amounts of water,
dramatically increases the swelling potential of the lime-stabilized
soil.
The main objectives of the current paper are to investigate the
effects of mellowing on the swelling properties of stabilized soils.
Engineering Geology 117 (2011) 170–179
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: + 44 1443 654829, + 44 7527101947 (Mobile).
E-mail address: mnrahmat@glam.ac.uk (M.N. Rahmat).
0013-7952/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enggeo.2010.10.015
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Engineering Geology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/enggeo