EFFECTS OF A NEEDLE ON HARTMANN-SPRENGER TUBE FLOWS
Guoping Xia
*
, Ding Li
†
and Charles L. Merkle
‡
The University of Tennessee
411 B. H. Goethert Parkway
Tullahoma, TN 37388, USA
ABSTRACT
A computational analysis of the effects of a needle on a
Hartmann-Sprenger tube driven by a Mach two jet is
presented. Solutions in the absence of a resonance tube
indicate that the ‘ideally’ expanded jet contains a
complex, but weak, Mach diamond pattern that is
essentially unaffected by a needle. The resonant
modes, however, are strongly impacted by a needle.
When a needle is not present, a 4 kHz screech mode is
generated with an oscillating shock in front of the tube.
When a needle is present, the high frequency modes are
suppressed and a quarter-wave (~550 Hz), regurgitant
oscillation is observed. Lengthening the needle causes
the high frequencies to decrease gradually and the
quarter wave to increase. Needles longer than the
nozzle tend to reduce the amplitude. The results are in
quantitative agreement with available measurements
and the trends are consistent with results for
underexpanded converging nozzles.
INTRODUCTION
A Hartmann-Sprenger tube is created by aligning a
blind tube with the axis of a jet so that the on-coming
flow is directed into its open end. This configuration
generates a variety of resonant conditions that have
attracted the attention of researchers for more than
three-quarters of a century. High frequency oscillations
*
PhD Student; Department of Mechanical Engineering,
tudent Member AIAA. S
†
Research Associate Professor; Department of Mechanical
Engineering, Computational Fluids Dynamics Research
roup; Member AIAA. G
‡
Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering; H. H.
Arnold Chair of Excellence in Computational Mechanics;
enior Member AIAA. S
Copyright © 2003 The American Institute of Aeronautics and
Astronautics, Inc. All rights reserved.
were first observed in a pitot tube by Hartmann [1]
while traversing the Mach diamond region of a
supersonic jet from an underexpanded convergent
nozzle. In later investigations, he reported that the
fluctuations were produced in regions of positive
pressure gradient by the oscillations of a strong normal
shock in front of the tube [2]. Sprenger noted that a
similar configuration could generate intense heating at
the closed end of the tube through the dissipation
generated by shocks inside the tube [3]. In addition, he
noted that even subsonic jets could produce heating if a
needle were placed along the axis or across the open
end of the tube.
Since these initial investigations, the mechanics of
Hartmann-Sprenger tubes have been the subject of
numerous experimental and analytical studies. Most
have used the non-uniform Mach diamond flowfield
downstream of an underexpanded convergent nozzle [4-
7], but resonance has also been generated in subsonic
jets [3, 8] and in ideally expanded supersonic jets [5].
In addition to these experiments in jet flowfields,
oscillations have been observed in tubes placed in
uniform subsonic [8, 9] and supersonic [9] flows.
Hartmann-Sprenger tubes have also been considered for
specific applications such as utilizing their heat-
generation capabilities for rocket engine ignition, [10];
or using them as fluid actuators for flow control [11-
13].
REVIEW OF PREVIOUS WORK
In reviewing the literature it is important to distinguish
between Hartmann-Sprenger tubes that make use of a
needle or other trip device and those that do not. Many
of above-mentioned experiments were conducted
without such a device, while others [5, 14] reported that
removing the needle caused the oscillations to decay to
zero. In the present paper, we look at the role of a
needle on the oscillation mechanisms behind a
divergent supersonic nozzle of a design used in recent
experiments [15].
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
1