CAAD Futures 2011 : Designing Together, ULg, 2011
© P. Leclercq, A. Heylighen and G. Martin (eds) 751
Change Detection in 3D Parametric Systems :
Human-Centered Interfaces for Change Visualization
NASIROVA Diliara, ERHAN Halil, HUANG Andy, WOODBURY Robert
and RIECKE Bernhard
Simon Fraser University, Canada
dnasirov@sfu.ca, herhan@sfu.ca, huang_a@sfu.ca, robw@sfu.ca, ber1@sfu.ca
Abstract. Research on current parametric modeling systems is mainly concerned
with the underlying computational technology and designs produced, with less
emphasis on human factors and design tasks. In these systems, users’ attention is
divided on system-imposed actions such as tool selection and set-up, managing
obscured views, frequent view manipulation, and switching between different
types of representations. In essence, control of the system can become more
demanding than the design task itself. Thus, we argue that this unbalanced
emphasis inhibits one of the most important functions of parametric design :
agility in exploration of design alternatives by applying frequent user-introduced
or system-generated changes on the parametric design models. This, compounded
by growing complexity of the models and the effect of cognitive limitations such
as change blindness, hinders change control and imposes an unnecessary
cognitive load in design. In this paper, we made a first step in investigating users’
visual cognitive challenges in the context of parametric design. The main research
question is to understand if change blindness significantly influences designers’
performance to detect and localize changes on a variety of models with different
placement of change visualization on interfaces. Quantitative and well as
qualitative results suggests that change blindness indeed occurs in this scenario
and likely reduces designers’ performance by making change detection highly
challenging, slow and confusing. Hence, change blindness should be considered
as an important factor in designing user interfaces that more effectively support
the human designer to focus on the design task, while offloading other tasks to the
system and getting adequate support from the computer.