Critical Review
Twenty-Year Systematic Review of the Hip
Pathology, Risk Factors, Treatment, and Clinical
Outcomes in Artistic Athletes—Dancers, Figure
Skaters, and Gymnasts
Ioanna Bolia, MD, MSc,* Hajime Utsunomiya, MD, PhD,* Renato Locks, MD,*
Karen Briggs, MPH, MBA,* and Marc J. Philippon, MD*†
Abstract
Objective: To identify (1) the predominant level of evidence of the clinical studies regarding the hip pathology, risk factors,
treatment, and clinical outcomes in artistic athletes (dancers, figure skaters, and gymnasts) (2) the most commonly reported hip
pathology, risk factors, treatments, and clinical outcomes in dancers, figure skaters, and gymnasts. Methods: To conduct this
systematic review PubMed, EMBASE, and Scopus databases were searched for relevant studies and pertinent data were collected
from the eligible articles. Included were studies which reported hip injuries in artistic athletes, the risk factors, treatment, and/or the
clinical outcomes. We excluded case reports or irrelevant studies. No meta-analysis was performed because of study heteroge-
neity. The methodical index for nonrandomized studies (MINORS) criteria were used for quality control. Main Results: Thirty-eight
studies were included in the analysis. The mean MINORS score was 13.6 6 4.6 points indicating fair quality of evidence of the
included articles. The predominant level of evidence was level IV. Chondrolabral pathology and muscle injuries were the most
commonly reported pathologies. We found only 2 risk factor analysis studies; however, many studies reported risk correlation
between artistic sports or imaging findings and hip pathology. Treatment strategies were reported in only 7 studies, clinical
outcomes are significantly underreported. Conclusion: Chondrolabral pathology was the most commonly reported hip pathology
in artistic athletes, however, prospective cohort studies are necessary to really understand these injuries and their associated risk
factors. The lack of clinical outcomes is significant and future data collection is required to assess the effectiveness of the various
treatments.
Key Words: hip labrum, ligamentum teres, ballet, ice skating, gymnastics, muscle
(Clin J Sport Med 2018;28:82–90)
INTRODUCTION
The presence of hip pathology in athletes may be the result of
an acute injury or an overuse syndrome. Labral tears,
acetabular and/or femoral head chondral defects, tearing of
the ligamentum teres, or joint instability are common.
1
Avascular necrosis of the femoral head in athletes, although
less common, can occur because of prolonged anabolic steroid
administration.
2
Diagnosis of hip pathology in athletes can
be challenging, partially because of the complex anatomy of
the joint which makes it difficult for the patient to localize the
pain.
3
Especially for labral tears, a study revealed that the
mean time from symptom manifestation to the definitive
diagnosis was 21 months, whereas these patients were seen by
3.3 healthcare providers on average before the establishment
of this diagnosis which was arthroscopically confirmed.
4
In
addition, pathology from the surrounding areas (sacroiliac
joint, abdomen, and groin) may manifest with hip pain.
3
Artistic sports, like dance, figure skating, and gymnastics,
may predispose the athletes to hip injuries because of repetitive
extreme range of motion in the hip joint during performance.
Although these 3 sports share some similar movements
(arabesque, attitude etc.) in terms of hip biomechanics, the
manifestation of hip pathology is sport-specific; the combi-
nation of joint hyperelasticity and acetabular dysplasia
(lateral center edge (CE) angle ,25 degrees) in dancers is an
example.
5,6
During gymnastics, the athlete often lands on his
feet after a high-jump movement which further increases the
load on the hip joint (hip flexion under stress).
7
Acceleration
phase in figure skating requires a “push off” motion of the hip
joint (push leg) in abduction and external rotation, similar to
the Peewee ice hockey sprint start.
8
The last has been shown be
an “at risk” hip maneuver. Based on the above, detailed
biomechanical analysis of each sport is necessary to deeply
understand the mechanisms that lead to hip injury.
However, it is important for the hip sports health profes-
sionals to be provided with appropriate clinical information to
be able to develop injury prevention strategies and improve the
clinical care of hip injuries in artistic athletes. For the purposes of
Submitted for publication December 30, 2016; accepted March 16, 2017.
From the *Steadman Philippon Research Institute, Vail, Colorado; and
†
The
Steadman Clinic, Vail, Colorado.
M. J. Philippon receives research support from National Institute of Health, National
Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal ans Skin Diseases, National Institute of
Aging, Smith and Nephew Endoscopy, Ossur, Arthrex, Siemens and Royalties from
Bledsoe, ConMed Linvatec, DonJoy, SLACK Iinc., Elsevier. M. J. Philippon is
stockholder of Arthrosurface, MJP Innovations, LLC, MIS, Vail Valley Medical
Center-Governing. The remaining authors report no conflicts of interest.
Corresponding Author: Marc J. Philippon, MD, Steadman Philippon Research
Institute, The Stedman Clinic, 181 West Meadow Drive, Suite 400, Vail, CO 81657
(karen.briggs@sprivail.org).
Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/JSM.0000000000000440
I. Bolia et al. (2018) Clin J Sport Med
Copyright Ó 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.