Verification & Validation of a Satellite Fault Detection and Isolation Scheme
Based on Sliding-Mode Observers
Andrés Marcos
+
; Halim Alwi, Chris Edwards
*
; Alex Falcoz
h
; Eric Bornschlegl
§
+ Deimos Space, Madrid, 28760, Spain
(e-mail: andres.marcos@ deimos-space.com)
* University of Leicester, Leicester, LE1 7RH, United Kingdom
(e-mail: {ha18, ce14}@ leicester.ac.uk)
h
EADS-Astrium SAS, Toulouse, France
(e-mail: Alexandre.FALCOZ@astrium.eads.net)
§
European Space Agency (ESA-ESTEC), Noordwijk, 2200 AG, The Netherlands
(e-mail: Eric.Bornschlegl@esa.int)
Abstract: In this article, the verification and validation (V&V) of a fault detection and isolation scheme
based on sliding mode observer residual evaluators and threshold-based residual analysis of gyro and
thruster faults for the Mars EXpress (MEX) satellite is presented. The results were part of a European
Space Agency project with the goal of examining the potential applicability of modern model-based FDI
techniques for on-board satellite deployment. The V&V campaign, consisting of firstly a set of specified
fault simulations and secondly a Monte Carlo campaign, has been performed using an industrial-level
functional engineering simulator developed around a high-fidelity model of the MEX satellite operating
during the Sun Acquisition Mode (SAM), which includes up to 6 different controller mode changes. The
results show the good performance and robustness of the FDI scheme throughout the SAM phase.
1. Introduction
Fault detection and isolation has increased in importance
during the last few decades as the level of autonomy expected
in engineering systems and devices has increased. Many
different methodologies have been considered and developed
– often arising from the application of concepts originating in
the field of control theory.
One application area for these developments has been
aerospace systems. In satellite systems there is an implicit
requirement to operate with minimal sensor and controller
hardware. However satellite deployment is expensive and
high risk – once deployed, if a fault occurs there is no
recourse, since it is usually prohibitively expensive to
XQGHUWDNH D VDWHOOLWH FDSWXUH¶ DQG UHSDLU PLVVLRQ 6DWHOOLWH
autonomy, therefore invariably requires a Fault Detection and
Isolation (FDI) scheme to detect malfunctions.
The results presented in this paper are part of a European
Space Agency (ESA) project with the goal of examining the
potential applicability of modern model-based FDI
techniques to on-board satellite deployment, in the present
case for the Mars Express during the Sun Acquisition Mode
phase. The FDI objective is to distinguish between actuator
and sensor faults during this phase, but the main objective of
the study is to show the applicability of modern model-based
FDI techniques to the industrial satellite process. Thus,
efforts are made to show the underlying methodology and
transparency (including tuning and implementation aspects)
of the proposed FDI design process.
2. Reference Mission, System & Objectives
The selected study case refers to the Mars EXpress (MEX)
during the Sun Acquisition Mode (SAM) phase [1, 2].
The model represents classical satellite dynamics with
flexible modes. There are no nonlinearities except for the
gyroscopic coupling terms and the uncertainties are
classically low on the inertias, but relatively high on the
flexible mode parameters (frequency, damping).
The available on-board sensing suite is composed of an
inertial measurement unit (SIRU) and a Sun Acquisition
Sensor (SAS) set. The gyro configuration within the SIRU is
a 4-axis configuration, while the SAS is redundant and
provides Sun direction (2-axis angle information).
The actuation system is composed of four tilted thrusters,
fully redundant, that provide 3-axis torque capability for the
AOCS. Reaction wheels are available on the spacecraft in
nominal mode but are not used during the SAM. In any case,
momentum is transferred from the wheel to the body at the
start of the acquisition due to friction torque.
The main objectives of the ESA-ESTEC study are
summarized as follows:
x An advanced technique is required that can deal with
thrusters and gyro FDI problems in the presence of time
varying dynamics, controller mode changes, noise and
uncertainties.
x The FDI objectives are to detect fault occurrence and
discriminate whether it belongs to the thrusters (opened or
closed faults) or the gyro sensors (dead, frozen, excessive
noise or excessive bias faults).
8th IFAC Symposium on Fault Detection,
Supervision and Safety of Technical Processes (SAFEPROCESS)
August 29-31, 2012. Mexico City, Mexico
978-3-902823-09-0/12/$20.00 © 2012 IFAC 277 10.3182/20120829-3-MX-2028.00167