Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of CO
2
Utilization
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jcou
Insight investigation of miscible
SC
CO
2
Water Alternating Gas (WAG)
injection performance in heterogeneous sandstone reservoirs
Duraid Al-Bayati
a,c,
⁎
, Ali Saeedi
a,
⁎
, Matthew Myers
b
, Cameron White
b
, Quan Xie
a
, Ben Clennell
b
a
Department of Petroleum Engineering, Curtin University, Kensington, WA, 6151, Australia
b
CSIRO Energy, Kensington, WA, 6151, Australia
c
Department of Petroleum Engineering, Kirkuk University, Kirkuk, Iraq
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Miscible WAG flooding
Effect of crossflow
Heterogeneous porous media
Enhanced oil recovery
ABSTRACT
In this manuscript, we present the results of a systematic approach to investigate the impact of core scale
heterogeneity on the efficiency of miscible CO
2
water-alternating-gas (WAG) flooding performance. Both vertical
(by layering two axially-cut half plugs with differing permeability) and horizontal (stacking two smaller core
samples with differing permeability in series) heterogeneities are explored. In the layered or vertically hetero-
geneous sample, the permeability ratio (PR) defines the ratio between the permeability values of each half plug.
Our special sample construction technique using either a thin impermeable Teflon sheet to prevent flow com-
munication or a thin tissue to promote flow communication has enabled us to investigate the effect of crossflow
between half plug on the performance of the WAG flood. For the stacked composite or the horizontally het-
erogeneous core samples, short cylindrical core segments were used each with a different permeability value. We
have also investigated the effect of the EOR injection mode (i.e. secondary vs. tertiary) on our results. For this
study, core flooding experiments were performed using n-C
10
, brine and CO
2
at a temperature of 343 K and a
pressure of 12.4 MPa.
The results obtained for homogeneous, layered and composite samples indicate that CO
2
WAG flood performs
better in all cases and achieves the highest recovery factor (RF) when conducted under the secondary mode (e.g.
homogeneous: 93.4%, layered: 74.0%, and composite: 90.9%) compared with the tertiary mode (e.g. homo-
geneous: 74.2%, layered: 64.1%, and composite: 71.3%). For the layered samples, it was found that the oil
recovery decreases noticeably with an increase in the permeability ratio (PR). For instance, RFs of 93.4%, 90.1%,
78.8%, and 74.0% correspond to PRs of 1, 2.5, 5, and 12.5, respectively. In contrast to our previous findings with
continuous CO
2
flooding which showed that crossflow enhances recovery in layered samples, for this study using
WAG, crossflow was found to negatively affect the RF. Such an outcome may be attributed to the conformance
control achieved by WAG flooding which would be more pronounced in the case of non-communication layers
(i.e. no cross flow). In other words, the higher oil recovery of WAG flooding in a non-communicating system may
be due to the dominance of viscous forces and, to a lesser extent, the vanishing effect of gravity forces that tend
to reduce sweep efficiency. The effect of composite heterogeneity on the RF was also investigated with the results
showing that the permeability sequence along the length of a composite sample has a noticeable but more subtle
impact on RF.
1. Introduction and background
Since the mid-20th century, many researchers have investigated the
suitability of CO
2
as an EOR agent and the field applications also re-
sulted in favourable outcomes [1–4]. With declining oil reserves
worldwide, CO
2
flooding for EOR has great potential for more wide-
spread use. Furthermore, in more recent years, it has been pointed out
that CO
2
injection into oil reservoirs can also be an effective approach
for mitigating the global warming and reducing greenhouse gas emis-
sions [5–7]. In fact, the application of CO
2
for EOR (CO
2
-EOR) may be
considered as an added advantage in helping to offset the cost asso-
ciated with CO
2
geo-sequestration processes making them economically
more attractive.
Generally, CO
2
-injection can prolong a reservoir’s life by 15–20
years and may recover an additional 15–20% of the original oil in place
[8]; this is mainly due to the high microscopic displacement efficiency
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcou.2018.10.010
Received 3 July 2018; Received in revised form 8 October 2018; Accepted 11 October 2018
⁎
Corresponding authors at: Department of Petroleum Engineering, Curtin University, Kensington, WA, 6151, Australia.
E-mail addresses: duraid.al-bayati@curtin.edu.au (D. Al-Bayati), Ali.saeedi@curtin.edu.au (A. Saeedi).
Journal of CO₂ Utilization 28 (2018) 255–263
2212-9820/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T