A Preliminary Evaluation of a Flexible Needle Steering Algorithm
Using Magnetic Resonance Images as Feedback
Pedro Moreira, Gert van de Steeg, Ferdi van der Heijden, Jurgen J. Fütterer and Sarthak Misra
Abstract— Needle-based procedures are commonly per-
formed for cancer diagnosis and treatment. Imaging modalities
are used to visualize the needle tip and the target during
these needle insertion procedures. Among the available imaging
techniques, magnetic resonance (MR) offers the best tissue
contrast, where detection of an early stage cancer is possible.
MR-guided needle insertions are currently performed with
rigid needles, which have limited steerability. Flexible needles
have been introduced to increase the steerability during the
insertion. In this paper, we present a preliminary evaluation
of a steering method for flexible bevel-tipped needles using
MR as an imaging modality. The steering algorithm uses a
needle deflection model to predict the tip motion and calculate
the optimal rotation to reach the target. The best sequence
of rotations are defined by an optimization algorithm based
on the Nelder-Mead technique. The needle tip and the target
are manually tracked through a graphical user interface. The
needle is inserted by a device fabricated with MR-compatible
material. The MR-guided flexible needle steering is evaluated
by a series of insertions in two phantoms with real obstacles
and targets. The average targeting error with flexible needles
is 4.3mm, which is 28% lower than the values reported in the
literature with rigid needles. The results indicate the feasibility
of MR-guided flexible needle insertions.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Early detection and treatment are of major importance to
reduce cancer mortality rate. Several diagnostic and treat-
ment techniques require needle insertion procedures, such as
biopsy and brachytherapy. The success of such techniques are
closely dependent on the needle placement accuracy. During
needle insertion procedures, medical imaging modalities are
used by clinicians to identify the needle tip and the target
locations. Ultrasound (US) imaging is the commonly used
technique to guide the needle towards a target due to its
simplicity and real-time imaging [1]. However, US images
present a poor tissue contrast and an early stage cancer lesion
might not be visible [2]. Computed tomography (CT) offers
a better tissue contrast than US, but the lack of real-time
imaging and the toxic radiation delivered to the patient are
important shortcomings [3]. On the other hand, magnetic
resonance (MR) imaging offers high resolution images of
tissues, in which the detection of early stage cancers is
possible, without toxic radiations. Nonetheless, MR-guided
The authors are affiliated with MIRA - Institute for Biomedical Technol-
ogy and Technical Medicine (Robotics and Mechatronics Group), University
of Twente, The Netherlands. Jurgen J. Fütterer is also affiliated with the
Department of Radiology, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre,
The Netherlands.
This research is supported by funds from the Dutch Ministry of Economic
Affairs and the Province of Overijssel, within the Pieken in de Delta
(PIDON) Initiative, Project: MIRIAM (Minimally Invasive Robotics In An
MRI environment).
Insertion device
Phantom
MR image
Target
Needle
Obstacles
Bevel tip
Fig. 1. A bevel-tipped flexible needle is steered towards a real target. The
user inserts and axially rotates the needle into a phantom with obstacles
using an insertion device. A magnetic resonance scanner is used as imaging
modality to track the needle and the target.
needle insertion faces many challenges due to the space
constraints of the MR bore, concerns about MR compatibility
and the difficulty of acquiring real-time images.
Several robotic devices have been developed to assist MR-
guided needle insertions. Fully automated MR-safe robotic
systems have been developed to insert rigid and flexible
needles [4], [5]. These systems are built with MR-compatible
materials and the needle is driven by pneumatic or piezoelec-
tric actuators. Semi-automated systems have been designed
to robotically position the needle guide, allowing a manual
needle insertion in the direction of the target [6], [7], [8].
Manual insertions are performed using thick and rigid nee-
dles while assuming that they follow a straight path. Those
needles have limited steerability and may induce target mo-
tion by tissue deformation. In the last decade, the use of thin
and flexible needles have been extensively studied in order
to reduce patient discomfort, tissue deformation and also
increase needle steerability [9], [10], [11]. However, those
needles have not yet been used on needle-based procedures
guided by MR images.
Several models and algorithms have been proposed to
steer bevel-tipped flexible needles. Webster et al. [9] and
Misra et al. [12] presented a kinematic and mechanics-
based models to steer a bevel-tipped flexible needle, re-
spectively. Two-dimensional (2D) steering algorithms are
2014 5th IEEE RAS & EMBS International Conference on
Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BioRob)
August 12-15, 2014. São Paulo, Brazil
978-1-4799-3127-9/6/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE 314