Accessing a hard to reach population: reflections on
research with young carers in Ireland
Danielle Kennan*, Allyn Fives† and John Canavan‡
*Researcher, †Postdoctoral Researcher, and ‡Lecturer and Associate Director, Child and Family Research Centre,
School of Political Science and Sociology, National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland
ABSTRACT
In keeping with developments in children’s rights, research is increas-
ingly including the views of children. Accessing a hard to reach
population of children can, however, raise significant ethical and
methodological challenges for researchers. Negotiating access
through gatekeepers, securing parental consent and limits on confi-
dentiality are central issues in the recruitment process of children.
This paper is based on a qualitative study of young carers in the Irish
population. It outlines the methodological approaches employed to
access a representative sample of young carers and the measures
taken to fulfil ethical obligations. In the recruitment phase of the
study, researchers attempted to strike a balance between two some-
times competing requirements, the need to protect children from
harm and to respect children’s competence. This paper reflects on the
success and limitations of the approaches adopted towards achieving
this balance, exploring the use of gatekeepers as a method to identify
and recruit a hidden population, and revisiting the measures taken to
comply with the ethical requirements of parental consent and limits
on confidentiality.
Correspondence:
Danielle Kennan,
The Child and Family Research
Centre,
School of Political Science and
Sociology,
The Science and Engineering
Technology Building,
National University of Ireland,
Galway,
Ireland
E-mail: danielle.kennan@nuigalway.ie
Keywords: access, ethics,
gatekeepers, hard to reach,
participation, young carers
Accepted for publication: April 2011
INTRODUCTION
An emerging respect for the agency of children has
resulted in a notable effort to include children as
active participants, as opposed to passive subjects of
research. This approach involves a commitment to
respect the competence of children, both the compe-
tence to ‘make decisions about whether to participate
in research’ and also the competence ‘to provide valid
sociological data’ (Morrow & Richards 1996, p. 98).
Adopting a participatory approach to research
respects a child’s right to express their views in all
matters affecting them as provided in Article 12 of the
UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UN
CRC). Twenty-one years have now passed since the
adoption of the UN CRC, and its almost universal
ratification underscores the international acceptance
of its principles. The general acceptance of children’s
agency in international law is reflected in develop-
ments in social science. The ‘new’ sociology of child-
hood conceptualizes children as social actors and has
equally been identified as a contributing factor to the
increasing focus on children’s agency in research
(Mason & Hood 2011).
In keeping with these developments a strong argu-
ment can be made that research, which is directly
relevant to the lives of children, should seek to capture
the views of those children. Not only does this
approach respect the right of children to have their
views heard in matters affecting them, but also the
participation of children can shed light on the reality
of their lives and thereby better inform the develop-
ment of legislation, policies and services. However, to
be inclusive in this way is a key challenge for research-
ers (Masson 2004, p. 45). As noted by Masson,
researchers cannot only include children who can be
‘readily contacted and are articulate’ (ibid). Efforts
must also be made to recruit hard to reach
doi:10.1111/j.1365-2206.2011.00778.x
1 Child and Family Social Work 2011 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd