Effects of density, PVC-tubes and feeding time on
growth, stress and aggression in African catfish
(Clarias gariepinus)
Jeroen G J Boerrigter
1
, Ruud van den Bos
1
, Hans van de Vis
2
, Tom Spanings
1
& Gert Flik
1
1
Organismal Animal Physiology, IWWR, Radboud University Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
2
IMARES, Wageningen UR, Yerseke, The Netherlands
Correspondence: J G J Boerrigter, Organismal Animal Physiology, IWWR, Radboud University Nijmegen, Heyendaalseweg 135,
6525 AJ Nijmegen, The Netherlands. E-mail: J.Boerrigter@science.ru.nl
Abstract
Successive exposure to aquaculture-related stres-
sors may compromise the allostatic capacity of
African catfish and lead to allostatic overload and
poor welfare. Therefore, we tested the effect of (i)
feeding during the light or dark phase, (ii) density
(51 fish per 140 L versus 51 fish per 43 L) and
(iii) altered available resting space/shelter on stress
handling were studied in African catfish (Clarias
gariepinus). Available resting space/shelter was
manipulated by providing PVC-tubes in the tanks.
Growth, baseline stress load (cortisol and osmolal-
ity), metabolism (glucose, lactate and non-esteri-
fied fatty acids) and aggression (measured by skin
scar incidence) were assessed. Upon completion of
the experimental period, we determined the adap-
tive capacity of the fish by the response to air
exposure. We show that night-feeding enhances
growth and lowers feed conversion ratio compared
to day-feeding. No effects of density were found for
baseline stress hormones, basal metabolism or
aggression. Low density seems to stimulate aggres-
sive behaviour after air exposure. Unexpectedly,
providing PVC-tubes under high-density conditions
increased aggression, raised baseline cortisol levels
and decreased basal metabolism as well as growth;
also the endocrine response to air exposure was
stronger. We argue that these effects relate to a
reduction in available space, i.e. a further increase
in density, or to an increased competition for shel-
ter. Overall, our data suggest that night-feeding
optimizes growth and that care should be taken in
using objects as shelter/enrichment for African
catfish.
Keywords: African catfish (Clarias gariepinus),
stress, aggression, density, enrichment, growth
Introduction
The growing human population increasingly
demands food, e.g. protein. One of the growing
sources for protein is fish. The quantity of fish
caught in the wild has stabilized over the past
years (FAO 2012). In contrast, the aquaculture
sector is fast growing (FAO 2010, 2012) and
expected to do so till 2025 (Diana 2009). In
2012, the sector provided 47% of the world’s fish
consumption (FAO 2012). The impact of increas-
ing numbers and volume of fish farms on the envi-
ronment and welfare of fish in aquaculture causes
public concern (Grigorakis 2010; Bovenkerk &
Meijboom 2012; EATIP 2012; Bergqvist & Gun-
narsson 2013). Sustainable aquaculture is a focus
point of the European Union (COM 299 2013);
noteworthy, animal welfare is an element of sus-
tainability (Gamborg & Sandøe 2005).
Animal welfare is defined in different ways
(Spruijt, van den Bos & Pijlman 2001; Korte, Oli-
vier & Koolhaas 2007; Broom 2011; Hagen, van
den Bos & de Cock Buning 2011; Ohl & van der
Staay 2012). Key to all definitions is that poor
welfare is associated with overtaxing the coping
capacity of animals (allostatic overload; McEwen &
Wingfield 2003). Allostatic overload results from
chronic stress and leads to pathologies and mortal-
ity (Koolhaas, Bartolomucci, Buwalda, de Boer,
Flugge, Korte, Meerlo, Murison, Olivier, Palanza,
Richter-Levin, Sgoifo, Steimer, Stiedl, van Dijk,
Wohr & Fuchs 2011). Successive or cumulative
© 2015 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 1
Aquaculture Research, 2015, 1–16 doi: 10.1111/are.12703