TECHNICAL ARTICLE
Testing of Glass Fiber Coalescing Filters
G. Belforte, T. Raparelli, and A. Trivella
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, Torino, Italy
Keywords
Efficiency Air – Oil Filters, Coalescent Filters,
Filter Media, Fiber Glass, Fibrous Filters
Correspondence
A. Trivella,
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace
Engineering, Politecnico di Torino,
Torino, Italy
Email: andrea.trivella@polito.it
Received: October 20, 2011; accepted:
December 19, 2011
doi:10.1111/j.1747-1567.2012.00806.x
Abstract
The paper presents an experimental study of coalescing filters for separating
oil from compressed air in industrial systems. A test bench for measuring filter
efficiency was set up which reproduces several typical operating conditions
of pneumatic systems. Tests were carried out on commercial products, using
filters of different sizes as well as several borosilicate cartridges of similar size
and shape. Preliminary analysis of cartridges indicated significant differences
in glass fiber dimensions and binder composition. Test results made it possible
to compare performance achieved by the different configurations in terms
of efficiency and pressure drop. Further measurements were repeated with
different cartridge supply system geometries. One of the tested filter-cartridge-
supply system configurations was then used to investigate system behavior
while varying certain operating parameters individually: air velocity, oil
concentration, filter supply pressure, and operating time. Results are presented
in statistical form.
Introduction
The compressed air in a pneumatic system is normally
moist and contaminated, containing by-products of
wear from moving parts, metal particles, and oxides,
and, often, quantities of oil resulting from compres-
sor lubrication or production needs. Coolers and
driers are used downstream of the compressor to
reduce condensation, while filters of varying grade
are provided along the line to retain solid particles
of different sizes. Removing oil is essential both in
order to ensure that the air is safe to breathe in the
area where it is released, and to guarantee the cleanli-
ness required for many applications, for example, food
processing, pharmaceuticals, metrology, or electronics
industries.
ISO 8573-1 classifies the cleanliness of air for
industrial use into several purity classes, according
to the concentrations and particle sizes of the solid
and liquid contaminants contained in the air. In
particular, permissible oil concentrations range from
5 to 0.01 mg/m
3
ANR (volume of air second the
‘‘Atmosfere Normale de Reference’’ conditions) with
purity classes from 4 to 0. Considering that oil
concentration at the compressor outlet can vary
from 0.2 to 2 g/m
3
, depending on machine wear,
the importance of the task performed by purification
filters is clear.
Coalescing filters are normally used to separate oil
from compressed air. These filters consist of a random
mass of inorganic fibers embedded in a binder fea-
turing a high porosity of around 90%. Various kinds
of binder are used: phenolic, epoxy, acrylic. As the
binder is chemically inert and nonabsorbent, it is capa-
ble of maintaining sufficient structural integrity over
time.
1
The volume actually occupied by the fibers as
a ratio of the total volume, that is, the packing frac-
tion, is small, which makes it possible to achieve low
pressure drops as air crosses the filter. Liquid particles
are captured by the fibers and slide toward the outer
surface of the filter, forming larger and larger droplets
as a result of coalescence until they fall by gravity into
the filter’s collection chamber. Coalescing filters can
also operate as particulate filters, taking advantage of
the fibers’ ability to capture solid contaminants.
Filtration efficiency, or the ratio of the concen-
tration of liquid retained and the amount entering
the filter, is determined by a number of mechanisms
involved in contaminant capture by the fibers.
2–4
These mechanisms are heavily dependent on the
relative dimensions of the particles and fibers, packing
fraction, and flow conditions.
Experimental Techniques (2012) © 2012, Society for Experimental Mechanics 1