Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Engineering Structures
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/engstruct
Major axis steel joint with additional plates subjected to torsion: Stiffness
characterization
Beatriz Gil
⁎
, Rufino Goñi, Eduardo Bayo
University of Navarra. Department of Construction, Services and Structures, 31009 Pamplona, Spain
ARTICLEINFO
Keywords:
Semi-rigid steel connections
Finite element models
Experimental research
Torsion
Warping
3D steel joint characterization
Out-of-plane behavior
ABSTRACT
This investigation deals with the characterization of the torsional behaviour of major axis steel joints with
doubled extended end-plate and additional plates welded to the column flanges at the height of the beam
flanges. One aim of this research is to provide the real joint torsional boundary conditions under which the beam
elements behave for frame analysis and stability checks, thus avoiding the need for simplifications such as
pinned or rigid joint conditions. Another objective is to characterize the stiffness of 3D joints, which requires
knowledge of each of the individual components, such as the ones studied in this investigation.
With this purpose two experimental tests were done, followed by a parametric study performed with cali-
brated finite element models that led to the analytical expressions of the components that characterize the
torsional stiffness of this kind of joints. After a detailed analysis, these joints were found to behave as semi-rigid
and full-strength. The semi-rigid behaviour is due to the torsional warping effects transmitted by the beam. The
results are also compared with those of the same joints but without additional plates (described in a recent
publication) and it is shown that the additional plates increase the joint stiffness significantly.
1. Introduction and objectives
The research on semi-rigid steel joints has been mainly focussed on
2D joints with in-plane loads and followed the component method pro-
posedinEurocode3Part1-8 [1].Newcombinationsorvariationsofthe
springs that represent every component, and the way of assembling
themhavebeenproposedbymanyauthors.Thereaderisreferredtothe
recently published Ref. [2] for a description on the progress of the 2D
component methods contained in the literature. However, the char-
acterization of 3D steel joints is a complex field in which many issues
still remain to be solved. Recent investigations have dealt with different
experiments as well as providing numerical and analytical solutions for
some of the components involved in this broad problem. The work
presented in [3] was focused on the experimental behaviour of 3D end-
plate joints with the aim of assessing the effect of the minor axis on the
behaviour of the major axis, as well as the interaction of the two minor
axis end-plate connections. In Ref. [4] a new 3D design for composite
joints was proposed and tested. It was found that due to the presence of
the concrete slab, the interactions between the loads in the beams did
not affect the overall joint behaviour in a significant way. Refs. [5] and
[6] describe the research of 3D joints with additional plates initially
using experimentation and later characterizing the newly called E-Stub.
3D joints under seismic loading were dealt with in Ref. [7], where a
new semi-rigid joint was proposed with the minor beam attached to the
column web by an end-plate connection and the major beam attached
to the column flange by a T-stub connection. The interaction between
the loadings in the minor and the major axes was also considered.
As mentioned before, most of reported studies are based on the
component method, but this method is still lacking when it comes to
defining the characteristics of 3D dimensional joints under out-of-plane
loads. In addition, the above mentioned interactions among the many
components that integrate the joint and the different loading conditions
(such as torsion) that may take place pose a serious challenge for a
direct application of the component method, especially for 3D cases.
Torsion, warping and lateral buckling in beam elements are usually
considered assuming simplified boundary conditions, such as pinned or
rigid, for frame analyses. Current codes allow advanced methods to
include more accurate boundary conditions; however, it is necessary to
previously characterize them properly. Ref. [8] presents a summary of
the different methods that have been developed to assess warping in
beams with restrained end supports, and also includes a method based
on bending analogy for the case of partially restrained supports.
The research reported in this paper is aimed at expanding the scope
of the component method and to define more accurate boundary condi-
tions for 2D and 3D joints under torsion. This work is a continuation of
the research reported in Refs. [9–13], which describe and analyse this
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engstruct.2020.111021
Received 14 February 2020; Received in revised form 18 May 2020; Accepted 24 June 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: bgilr@unav.es (B. Gil).
Engineering Structures 220 (2020) 111021
0141-0296/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T