RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS
Carbon Accounting in Harvested Wood
Products
Assessment Using Material Flow Analysis Resulting in Larger
Pools Compared to the IPCC Default Method
Gediminas Jasineviˇ cius, Marcus Lindner, Emil Cienciala, and Markku Tykkyl¨ ainen
Summary
Increasing the amount of carbon stored in harvested wood products (HWPs) is an inter-
nationally recognized measure to mitigate climate change. Several approaches and tiers of
methods may be used to analyze the contribution of HWP in terms of greenhouse gas emis-
sions and removals at a regional and national level. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change (IPCC) provides guidelines on three tiers of methods for estimating annual carbon
stock changes in the carbon pool of HWPs. These tiers mostly differ by the availability of
input data and the level of HWP aggregation. In this case study for the Czech Republic, we
have applied the production approach and alternative tiers of accounting methods, which
are described in the IPCC guidelines, including the default method (tier 2) and the most
advanced method (tier 3). We used country-specific data and material flow analysis to trace
the carbon flow over the entire forest-based sector, including only the domestic harvest and
the primary and secondary wood products manufactured within the country. The results
of this study show that the carbon stored in the HWP pool could be underestimated if
simpler methods and default values nonspecific to the country are applied. At the national
level, applying the tier 3 method resulted in a 15.8% higher annual carbon inflow in the
pool of HWPs compared to the tier 2 IPCC default method. This means that the advanced
method reveals an apparently higher carbon sink in HWPs. A documented increase of
carbon storage might bring additional credits to reporting countries, and, more important,
it could promote the use of long-life HWPs to mitigate climate change.
Keywords:
Climate-change mitigation
forest-based sector
harvested wood products (HWPs)
contribution
industrial ecology
production approach
wood industry
Supporting information is linked
to this article on the JIE website
Introduction
Background
Through photosynthesis, forests capture carbon dioxide
(CO
2
) from the atmosphere and store carbon in biomass. Af-
ter forest harvest, a significant amount of carbon is removed
and could be held for decades in harvested wood products
(HWPs) (Anderson et al. 2013). In the last decades, Euro-
pean forests have removed more carbon from the atmosphere
Address correspondence to: Gediminas Jasineviˇ cius, European Forest Institute, Sustainability and Climate Change Unit, Yliopistokatu 6, Joensuu 80101, Finland. Email:
gediminas.jasinevicius@efi.int; Web: www.efi.int
© 2017 by Yale University
DOI: 10.1111/jiec.12538 Editor managing review: Stefanie Hellweg
Volume 00, Number 0
than the amount that was released through burning or decom-
position of biomass (Nabuurs et al. 2013; Goodale et al. 2002).
It is estimated that European Union (EU) forests and the forest
sector currently produce an overall climate-mitigation impact
that amounts to around 13% of the total EU emissions (Nabuurs
et al. 2015). Approximately 10% of this carbon might be stored
in HWPs (Pilli et al. 2015). The use of wood is also associated
with lower emissions of CO
2
and other pollutants when com-
pared to alternative material (Gustavsson et al. 2006; Sathre
www.wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jie Journal of Industrial Ecology 1