ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Topographical Analysis of the Optic Nerve in
Migraine Patients
TERRY D. MOEHNKE, OD, MS, FAAO, JOSEPH SOWKA, OD, FAAO,
JOSEPHINE SHALLO-HOFFMANN, PhD, FAAO, PATRICK HARDIGAN, PhD, and
ALBERT D. WOODS, MS, OD, FAAO
College of Optometry (TDM, JS, JS-H, ADW), and Office of Assessment, Evaluation and Faculty Development (PH),
Nova Southeastern University, Fort Lauderdale, Florida
ABSTRACT
Purpose. Vascular dysfunction appears related to the development of migraines and has been associated with pressure-
independent glaucoma. The purpose of this study is to investigate possible topographical differences in the optic nerve
between migraine sufferers and normal age-matched control subjects. The identification of optic disc topographical
differences between migraine and non-migraine sufferers may help clinicians determine if the presence of migraine
influences the development and progression of glaucoma.
Methods. Sixty consecutively seen patient-volunteers (30 subjects in migraine group: mean age 37.7 years, range from
19 to 66 years, 28 females and 2 males; 30 subjects in the control group: mean age 37.6 years, range from 19 to 61 years,
29 females and 1 male) were categorized as either migraine patients or control group subjects. All migraine subjects had
been medically diagnosed with a migraine syndrome and were being treated with prophylactic medication. Optic nerve
head topographical analysis was performed using a confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscope. The data was evaluated
using generalized estimating equations, a priori and post hoc power analysis.
Results. No significant differences were found in any of the optic nerve parameters examined between the two groups.
Conclusions. This study indicates that the optic nerve parameters as measured by the Heidelberg retinal tomograph II do
not differ between migraine sufferers and age-matched control subjects.
(Optom Vis Sci 2008;85:566–573)
Key Words: migraine, glaucoma, topography, optic nerve, generalized estimating equations
A
n estimated 29 million people in the United States suffer
from migraine headaches, with women almost three times
as likely to suffer from the headaches as men.
1
Migraine
headache occurs in 3 to 10% of all children and up to 25% of
adolescents with the peak prevalence occurring between the ages of
35 to 45 years.
2
Migraine is a chronic, recurrent neurological con-
dition resulting in periodic attacks of head pain which may cause a
one-sided pulsating moderate or severe headache. These headaches
may last for several hours accompanied by gastrointestinal upsets
and heightened sensitivity to bright lights and noise. In some cases
migraines can convert from occasional episodic attacks to a chronic
condition
3
which in turn can lead to subclinical brain lesions.
4,5
Faced with only subjective complaints that may be misleading
and no standardized diagnostic tests, physicians must rely on the
patients’ description of the pain and associated symptoms to de-
termine if migraine is present. The Headache Classification Com-
mittee of the International Headache Society developed a stan-
dardized system that utilizes clinical presentation and laboratory
tests to include or exclude features that are needed to establish a
particular diagnosis.
6
The diagnosis of migraine under the Inter-
national Headache Society criteria is based on the patient’s report
of previous headache attacks and specific descriptive steps that
assess disability, nausea, and photophobia.
7,8
The etiology of migraine is unknown but several theories have
been presented in an effort to explain the pathophysiology. In the
late 1930s, Graham and Wolff determined the temporal artery
dilated during a migraine attack and this lead to the pain associated
with the headache attack.
9
Wolff hypothesized the aura that pre-
ceded the headache and the visual symptoms associated with the
migraine attack were the result of vasospasm that lead to the re-
duction of blood flow to the brain. The clinical concept of vaso-
spasm was first described in the late 1850s by Gull who reported
1040-5488/08/8507-0566/0 VOL. 85, NO. 7, PP. 566–573
OPTOMETRY AND VISION SCIENCE
Copyright © 2008 American Academy of Optometry
Optometry and Vision Science, Vol. 85, No. 7, July 2008