Journal of Modern Physics, 2013, 4, 174-179
http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/jmp.2013.42024 Published Online February 2013 (http://www.scirp.org/journal/jmp)
Spiky Development at the Interface in Rayleigh-Taylor
Instability: Layzer Approximation with
Second Harmonic
Rahul Banerjee
1,2*
, Labakanta Mandal
1
, Manoranjan Khan
1
, Mithil Ranjan Gupta
1
1
Department of Instrumentation Science, Centre for Plasma Studies, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, India
2
St. Paul’s Cathedral Mission College, Raja Rammohan Roy Sarani, Kolkata, India
Email:
*
rbanerjee.math@gmail.com
Received June 19, 2012; revised October 20, 2012; accepted November 13, 2012
ABSTRACT
Layzer’s approximation method for investigation of two fluid interface structures associated with Rayleigh Taylor in-
stability for arbitrary Atwood number is extended with the inclusion of second harmonic mode leaving out the zeroth
harmonic one. The modification makes the fluid velocities vanish at infinity and leads to avoidance of the need to make
the unphysical assumption of the existence of a time dependent source at infinity. The present analysis shows that for an
initial interface perturbation with curvature exceeding
1 2 A , where A is the Atwood number there occurs an almost
free fall of the spike with continuously increasing sharpening as it falls. The curvature at the tip of the spike also in-
creases with Atwood number. Certain initial condition may also result in occurrence of finite time singularity as found
in case of conformal mapping technique used earlier. However bubble growth rate is not appreciably affected.
Keywords: Rayleigh Taylor Instability; Bubble; Spike; ICF; Supernova
1. Introduction
Hydrodynamic instabilities such as Rayleigh Taylor in-
stability (RTI) which sets in when a lighter fluid supports
a heavier fluid against gravity or Richtmyer Meshkov
instability (RMI) which is initiated when a shock passes
an interface between two fluids with different acoustic
impedances are of increasing importance in a wide range
of physical phenomena starting from inertial confinement
fusion (ICF) to astrophysical ones like supernova explo-
sions. In ICF, the capsule shell undergoes the RTI both in
the acceleration and deceleration phases. RTI can retard
the formation of the hot spot by the cold RTI spike of
capsule shell resulting in the destruction of the ignition
hot spot or autoignition [1-4]. The hydrodynamic insta-
bilities lead to development of heavy fluid “spikes” pene-
trating into the lighter fluid and “bubbles” of lighter fluid
rising through the heavier fluid. Different approaches
have been used for the study of such problems. Among
these Layzer’s [5] approach applied to single mode po-
tential flow model [6-11] is a useful one giving approxi-
mate estimate of both Rayleigh Taylor and Richtmyer
Meshkov instability evolution. The bubbles were shown
by Zhang [7] to rise at a rate tending asymptotically to a
terminally constant velocity while spikes were shown to
descend with a constant acceleration. However, whether
for bubbles or for the spikes, Zhang’s analysis was ap-
plicable only for Atwood number A = 1, i.e., only for
fluid-vacuum interface. An extension to arbitrary value
of Atwood number A was done by Goncharov [8]. With-
in limitations of Layzer’s model as pointed out by Mi-
kaelian [12] bubbles were shown to rise with a velocity
tending to an asymptotic value dependent on A and hav-
ing a fairly close agreement with the simulation results of
Ramaprabhu et al. [13]. But the spikes were found to
descend with a terminal constant velocity in contrast to a
constant acceleration as obtained by Zhang [7] for A = 1.
Asymptotic spike evolution in Rayleigh Taylor insta-
bility behaving almost as a free fall was obtained by
Clavin and Williams [14] and also by Duchemin et al.
[15] by conformal mapping method. Associated with the
free fall of the spike, the surface curvature of the spike
was also found to increase with time (i.e. the spike shar-
pens as it falls).
The present paper described the dynamics of bubble
and spike tips arising at the two fluid interfacial structure
due to RTI with extended Layzer’s model replacing the
zeroth harmonic term [8] by second harmonic term to
satisfy the condition that the fluid velocity vanishes at
*
Corresponding author.
Copyright © 2013 SciRes. JMP