© koninklijke brill nv, leiden, | doi:./-
PNEUMA () –
brill.com/pneu
Complementarianism and Egalitarianism—Whose
Side Are You Leaning On?
A Pentecostal Reading of Ephesians 5:21–33
Melissa Archer
Southeastern University, Lakeland, Florida
mlarcher@seu.edu
Kenneth J. Archer
Southeastern University, Lakeland, Florida
kjarcher@seu.edu
Abstract
With the growing acceptance of same-sex marriage among Christian communities
and the increasing concern of the influence of the LGBTQIA communities upon pol-
itics, there has been a resurgent concern to reaffirm “male headship” for church, state
and marriage. Emphasizing so-called biblical gendered roles has become a way to
argue against feminism and same-sex marriage. Along with the resurgence of the tra-
ditional understanding of divine order as patriarchy comes an undermining of women
in leadership roles, especially in ministry. Pentecostals generally have been more lib-
eral (challenging the tradition of patriarchy as related to ministry) than conservative
(maintaining that females should be silent in church and subject to male authority)
regarding females in ministry. In this article we will state fairly and accurately the two
contemporary positions—complementarian and egalitarian—by drawing primarily
from their official websites and key theologians, and then present a pentecostal read-
ing/hearing of Ephesians 5:21–33. We will exegetically engage the passage and then
raise important questions concerning these understandings in light of a pentecostal
hermeneutical perspective that privileges Luke-Acts, especially Acts 2. The goal will be
to understand the passage and then move toward a pentecostal egalitarian understand-
ing of humanity and society, thus affirming the beauty and dignity of female and male
without affirming the hierarchical position of patriarchy or matriarchy.