Research and Theory for Nursing Practice: An International Journal, Vol. 18, No. 1, 2004
© 2004 Springer Publishing Company 15
Development of a Theoretical Construct
for Risk and Vulnerability From
Six Empirical Studies
Jeanne M. Leffers
University of Massachusetts, Dartmouth
Diane C. Martins
Margaret M. McGrath
Deborah Godfrey Brown
Judith Mercer
Mary C. Sullivan
Paula Viau
University of Rhode Island, Kingston
The concepts of risk and vulnerability are frequently the subject of nursing schol-
arship but lack semantic and conceptual clarity in the nursing literature. Using empir-
ical evidence from 6 research studies, the authors define the concepts of risk and
vulnerability, apply shared definitions to each of the study populations, and discuss
3 types of responses to risk observed in the research setting. This collaborative effort
by nursing scholars advances conceptual clarity of risk and vulnerability for the
development of nursing knowledge. Further, the examination of risk responses has
the potential to link the various perspectives of risk and vulnerability common in
nursing and generate nursing practice implications explored in this review.
Keywords: risk; vulnerability; resilience; resourcefulness; health outcomes
N
ursing literature reports extensive examples of nurses’ experiences with
persons or groups that are at risk and/or vulnerable to poor health out-
comes. However, diverse philosophical, theoretical, and methodological
perspectives among scholars impede the development of semantic and concep-
tual clarity of risk and vulnerability for knowledge development in nursing. The pri-
mary purpose of this paper is to clarify the conceptual distinctions between risk
and vulnerability. Second, responses to risk, specifically resilience and resource-
fulness, will be specified and explored. Third, we will examine empirical evidence
from six studies using shared conceptual definitions of risk and vulnerability. The
shared conceptual definitions developed from our various perspectives and, applied
to the studies, serve to advance semantic clarity for nursing. Further, the risk