www.advenergymat.de
FULL PAPER
1801781 (1 of 11) ©
2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Enhanced Cycling Stability of Macroporous Bulk Antimony-
Based Sodium-Ion Battery Anodes Enabled through Active/
Inactive Composites
Olivia Ruiz, Mark Cochrane, Manni Li, Yan Yan, Ke Ma, Jintao Fu, Zeyu Wang,
Sarah H. Tolbert, Vivek B. Shenoy, and Eric Detsi*
DOI: 10.1002/aenm.201801781
resources used in commercial LIBs.
[1–3]
The desire to keep pace with a growing
market has led to intensive research of
alternative rechargeable battery technolo-
gies that utilize earth-abundant elements,
such as sodium- and magnesium-ion
batteries (SIBs and MIBs).
[2,4–10]
While
progress towards practical MIBs is hin-
dered by the lack of suitable electrolytes
that are compatible with Mg metal,
[10–14]
a major challenge with SIBs corresponds
to the fact that achieving energy densi-
ties equal to, or exceeding LIBs requires
high-capacity anode materials such as
phosphorus (2596 mAh g
-1
for Na
3
P),
tin (847 mAh g
-1
for Na
3
Sn), antimony
(660 mAh g
-1
for Na
3
Sb), etc.
[15,16]
Among these candidate materials, Sb
is particularly promising because of its
exceptionally fast kinetics during Na
insertion.
[17–20]
As with common high-
capacity anode materials, phase trans-
formations associated with alloying
reactions of Sb with Na give rise to large
mechanical stresses and huge volume
expansions of up to 400% during full
sodiation.
[19–26]
In turn, these expansions break the electrical
contact between the active materials (i.e., Sb grains) and
other electrode components including the binder, conductive
additives, and current collector.
[27–32]
This ultimately leads to
battery failure after limited cycling. A common strategy to
Engineering strategies based on “nanostructuring” and “active/inactive
composites” are commonly used separately to improve the performance of
alkali-ion battery electrodes. Here, these two strategies are merged to further
enhance the performance of alloy-type alkali-ion battery anodes. Specifically,
macroporous antimony (Sb)/magnesium fluoride (MgF
2
) active/inactive
composite material is used as a high-performance Na-ion battery anode.
The porous Sb phase with pore size in the sub-micrometer range acts as
the electrochemically active component and the electrochemically inactive
dense MgF
2
phase acts as a mechanical buffer. Na-ion battery anodes made
of porous Sb/MgF
2
active/inactive composites are reversibly sodiated for
over 300 cycles, delivering a capacity of ≈551 mAh g
-1
after 300 cycles at a
C-rate of C/2. This performance is remarkable because the porous Sb/MgF
2
composite is not made of mesoporous structures. Furthermore, the cycling
longevity of this porous Sb/MgF
2
composite outperforms the common nano-
structured Sb-based Na-ion battery anode materials. This good performance
is attributed to the “porous active/inactive” configuration, where the dense
inactive mechanical buffer phase absorbs part of the phase transformation-
induced stresses, while porosity in the active phase helps to accommodate
the phase transformation induced volume expansions and electrolyte transfer
into the bulk of this composite.
Sodium-Ion Batteries
O. Ruiz, M. Cochrane, M. Li, K. Ma, J. Fu, Z. Wang,
Prof. V. B. Shenoy, Prof. E. Detsi
Department of Materials Science and Engineering
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, PA 19104-6272, USA
E-mail: detsi@seas.upenn.edu
M. Li
School of Materials Science and Engineering
Harbin Institute of Technology
Harbin 150001, China
Dr. Y. Yan, Prof. S. H. Tolbert
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry
University of California Los Angeles
Los Angeles, CA 90095-1569, USA
Z. Wang
State Key Laboratory of Advanced Welding and Joining
Harbin Institute of Technology
Harbin 150001, China
Prof. S. H. Tolbert
The California NanoSystems Institute
University of California Los Angeles
Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA
Prof. E. Detsi
Vagelos Institute for Energy Science and Technology (VIEST)
Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA
1. Introduction
The rechargeable battery industry is currently dominated by
lithium-ion battery (LIB) technology, however there is growing
concern for the limited availability of raw lithium and cobalt
Adv. Energy Mater. 2018, 1801781