International Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing 5: 207-215 (1988)
©Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht- Printed in the Netherlands
Experimental identifcation of technical and database factors that can afect
the success of clinical computer systems
Daniel J. Essin
Department of Pediatrics, Universit of Souther Califoria School of Medicine, Los Angeles, Califoria,
USA
Accepted 12 January 1988
Key word: computer software, database management systems, transaction processing, software tools,
clinical information systems
Summary
The entry of clinical data into computer systems is an extremely demanding form of transaction processing.
High speed is important, especially if the collection involves real-time data. Clinicians must feel that they
intuitively understand a system and that it is responsive. Medical data must be easily accommodated without
sacrificing accuracy or completeness. Most systems cannot do this. Clinical systems that involve on-line
storage of data fom patients should employ data-base technology. Systems that lack any of the following
capabilities will not succeed: manual data entry, a data dictionary, a file system, utility functions, ad hoc
query, and a statistical report generator. Tese general capabilities must satisfy a number of specific
functional requirements if the entire system is to be a success. A group of such requirements have been
experimentally validated. These will be discussed and a more comprehensive list presented.
Introduction
Computerization in a critical care or general hospi
tal setting involves more than the purchase of pre
fabricated commercial systems. Some institutions
have chosen to specialize in technologically inten
sive areas such as cardiac surgery. Others are re
search oriented and collect large amounts of data,
both textual and real-time physiological, that ex
ceed the minimum required to provide treatment.
Many government and academic institutions are
subject to logistic and regulatory constraints that
are uncommon in the private sector. These special
ized circumstances necessitate the development of
customized systems either as extensions of a cen
tralized hospital information system or independ
ently.
Although the need to computerize in order to
perform a particular function may be evident, the
need alone does not guarantee success. The num
ber of medical systems that have failed in the past
attests to the need for a quantitative understanding
and definition of the components of successful sys
tems. The characteristics that defne general suc
cess are listed in Table 1.
The purpose of the present study is to experi
mentally identify those specific features of comput
er database management systems that have a mate
rial impact on general success and functionality.
Critical care and laboratory applications that re
quire custom real-time programming are especially
dependent on factors that promote general success
since most of the available resources are invariably
directed at achieving the specific success of the
project.